The Mansion Tax is a fundamentally flawed proposal
by Luke Chapman
The Labour Party recently announced a plan to place a so called “mansion tax” on high value properties. Specifically, this would involve an annual levy of 1% on the value of any home worth over £2million, the proceeds of which would be used to fund a new 10p tax rate on income. Both aspects of this policy are poorly thought out and leave much to be desired.
The idea of a mansion tax has been bandied around for some time by the Liberal Democrats, in particular Vince Cable. However, the levy has too many pitfalls to ever be enacted successfully and is a more cumbersome, unfair alternative to the 50p tax rate.
My primary concern with the proposal is the potential effect on the elderly. Many pensioners bought a home decades ago and have seen its value skyrocket in recent years, while their incomes have remained fairly static in comparison. Savills research estimate that one third of properties worth over £2million have been owned for at least 10 years, while 15% have been owned for over 20 years, reinforcing the likelihood that many pensioners on fairly average incomes could find their home is valued over the mansion tax threshold. Another instance where the value of buildings could far outstrip the ability of the owners to pay the tax would be family farms. An annual levy of over £20,000 is crippling for an individuals in these situations, and is categorically unjust.
The tax would be particularly unfair on those who live in London and the South East, where house prices are significantly higher than the rest of the country. Many people have jobs in the capital and therefore have to buy a house that is within commuting distance; it is not their fault that houses are so expensive in these areas and an additional tax simply amplifies the difficulties.
Enforcing a mansion tax is no simple task either, house valuations are by their very nature subjective and difficult to pinpoint exactly, but for the tax to work properly every house needs to be valued and then taxed on this criterion. As a result, a mansion tax will create huge administrative costs for the government and raise questions about whether valuation decisions can be challenged by homeowners.
Disruption to the housing market would result, as homeowners with properties over £2 million will be prompted to sell their homes and buy property whose value lies under the threshold, increasing the price of such property, moving House prices away from their intrinsic value, and causing what economists might term a “welfare loss”.
If the measure were put in place, individuals would be taxed on their income, the purchase of a home and then keeping the property. Being taxed three times on effectively the same pot of money is a ridiculous set of circumstances, notwithstanding the chance of being taxed again if the house was passed on in the form of an inheritance. Constant taxation of the same asset like this goes beyond the pale and serves as a huge disincentive to homeowners looking to move up the property ladder.
The re-enactment of the 50p tax rate for very high earners would be a much simpler, more efficient method of taxation. It would target almost exactly the same individuals but would avoid the issue of ensnaring asset rich, income poor individuals like the mansion tax. This proposal is still progressive and dovetails neatly with system already in place, cutting down on the costs of implementation.
The introduction of a 10p tax rate also strikes me as odd. The Institute of Fiscal Studies, a well-known research institute, comment that continuing to raise the Personal Tax Allowance, which is the level of income on which no tax is payable, is a much more sensible way to achieve the aim of providing tax relief for those on lower incomes. An increase in the personal tax allowance would also be a much more progressive measure and has already been put in motion by the current government.
The message of Ed Milliband’s statement is broadly reasonable: those who can afford to should pay a little more to help people who are suffering most in the current economic climate. However, a mansion tax is a heavy handed, inefficient and misguided way of going about it and should be scrapped in favour of the much simpler 50p tax rate.

