The male identity crisis

By Simon Forest

Nowadays we hear a lot about ‘lad culture’ at Britain’s universities. This culture is, we are told, one of unrestrained drinking, academic underachievement and, most importantly of all, pervasive sexism. However, despite widespread alarm in the media there has been little critical attention paid to the phenomenon with concern focusing instead on how widespread the issue is.

bar 3

For those interested in its extent, I recommend reading the NUS report, “That’s What She Said”, which makes for fascinating, if not particularly cheery, reading. However, with regards to this article, the exact extent of ‘lad culture’ is in a sense irrelevant; the report makes it very clear that it has had a significant impact upon students’ experiences at university.

It seems that as a discourse on gender relations the concept of ‘lad culture’ is here to stay. Besides, due to media coverage this image of the ‘uni lad’ is becoming increasingly associated with how the outside world views university culture and particularly male students.

With this in mind it seems that an exploration of masculinity and ‘lad culture’ might be profitable and provide new insights on the issue. It is in this spirit that I will seek to explore some different angles on ‘lad culture’ and suggest areas where further analysis might be profitable.

The first thing which we need to make clear is the fact that there is no such thing as the ‘uni lad’.

In reality people tend to be more complicated than two-dimensional types.’Laddism’ is just one of many different models of masculinity which are drawn on to varying degrees to help construct personal identity in relations to groups, both real and imagined.

The first thing which we need to make clear is the fact that there is no such thing as the ‘uni lad’

This means that ultimately most men, and probably a significant number of women, would fall somewhere on a ‘lad spectrum’, ranging from the occasional use of ‘that’s what she said’ to a much fuller participation in a culture of drinking and sexism.

My point here is not to try to draw a line, to separate a harmless ‘lad’ from a dangerous sexual predator, but instead to try to show that these are individuals with thoughts, feelings and values and that we need to try to understand them rather than simply condemning them (not to suggest that their actions should not also be condemned).

In many ways this makes the problem more worrisome as we cannot simply dismiss them as somehow fundamentally different from others but as being close, sometimes uncomfortably so, to our own experience. However, we also need to appreciate that emphasising a single ‘lad’ stereotype may be too simplistic in helping us to understand the complex dynamics at play in the creation of individual identity.

With this in mind it is important to note that the problem of the ‘uni lad’ is fast becoming the main symbol of student masculinity in popular culture

With this in mind it is important to note that the problem of the ‘uni lad’ is fast becoming the main symbol of student masculinity in popular culture.

This is not to suggest that ‘lads’ are the only models of masculinity or even the most common ones but simply that they are becoming the most visible. This can lead to articles which often seem to carry insinuations that all male students are somehow complicit in this culture and as a man my natural reaction to such articles is to dismiss it as hyperbole.

It is easy to be adamant that we, the ‘decent men’, are not part of the problem and should not be tarred with the same brush as these ‘lads’. However, this does not change two facts: one, we are being tarred with the same brush whether fair or not; and two, ‘laddism’ is an element of masculinity even if that makes us uncomfortable. I should stress this does not mean that it is an element of the identity of every male, just that it is one element in a vast and evolving cultural and imaginative concept which acts as a reference point for most men in forming their identities.

As I have already said the natural response of many men, and one of which I am certainly guilty, is to view articles on ‘lad culture’ as inapplicable to them.

They are sure, and in many cases justifiably, that they are not part of the problem.

However, the two facts above should make us think again about whether our engagement with the issue should end there.

As I have already said the natural response of many men, and one of which I am certainly guilty, is to view articles on ‘lad culture’ as inapplicable to them

Firstly, and regrettably cynically, the increasing media attention to this phenomenon is creating an image of male students; an image which reflects negatively on and influences reactions to all of us regardless of our own actions. Clearly this is not a desirable situation for fellow male students. Secondly, we have a privileged position to influence the culture of male university students because, as men, we have greater and more straightforward access to the cultural resource, masculinity (or masculinities as is often the preferred term in more academic discussions of gender).

With this in mind, I have found it useful to move beyond the simple assertion that ‘I am not part of the problem’ and recognise the fact that I may have the potential to be part of the solution.

 It is worth discussing exactly what this means in greater detail. As we have already seen ‘lads’ are not actually mindless stereotypes and it is possible that, if provided with more models of masculinity to draw upon and placed in a more open homosocial environment, they may construct their personal identities and values quite differently to the ways they currently do so.

As male students we should direct our energies to strengthening alternative cultures which are not ‘laddish’ and making them more visible.

As a side note we must be careful not to fall into the trap of becoming ‘gentlemen’. We should not try to resuscitate a patronising and ‘chivalric’ attitude towards women which revolves around equally sexist attitudes. Instead we must construct masculinities which engage with women as equals and as individuals who are not solely defined by their gender (just as surely we wish not to be solely defined by our gender).

I do not know precisely what form this masculinity or masculinities should take but the key is to open a debate.

As a side note we must be careful not to fall into the trap of becoming ‘gentlemen’

For a long time gender debates were considered almost synonymous with women’s issues and although the academic world has begun increasingly to explore masculine experience and identity, sadly this has not trickled down into society at large and discussions between men about what masculinity means are not common and it is, perhaps, unfortunate that the NUS report did not consult any students who identified as male on the issue.

The point of this article is twofold. The first has been to present an individual male opinion on ‘lad culture’ and to suggest some ways in which a more complex appreciation of the phenomenon may provide us with solutions to the issue. The second is to call for a broader debate within the university on issues of masculinity which would contribute to the welfare of all university students; help counter the unpleasant culture in which many, particularly women, find themselves; and provide men with new insights and resources in the construction of their own masculine identities.

Photograph: Emma Werner