Twitter must be free to perform its function
by Francesca Moll
As I’m sure you’ll all have heard, we being trendy young students and down with the social media and all that, someone is trying to sue all of Twitter.
Lord McAlpine, who was wrongly assumed to have been being investigated in connection with the Jimmy Savile paedophile probe, and who was subjected to an infamous “Twitchfork mob” of abuse and mockery on Twitter, has hired a team of lawyers to track down every single sad 30-year-old computer geek to their mother’s basement and make them pay up for their snarky 140-character comment.
Now, Lord McAlpine’s behaviour in this, I would say, is entirely understandable. The emotional trauma and irreparable damage to this poor man’s reputation, whose career is, after all, based on being in the public eye, must have been enormous. It is entirely reasonable to expect some kind of justice from the ringleaders of the pack of trolls that briefly made his life a living hell.
But what bothers me is how the journalists are reacting. Do a brief search on the comment sections of most major newspapers, and you will find most of the writers sniggering with barely concealed relish over this slap on the wrist for everyone’s favourite social networking site: “Don’t press send: why restraint is a fine old virtue for a tweeting world” and “In the Tower of Babel that is Twitter, silence descends. Quite right, too”, to name but a couple of titles of these opinion pieces. And those are the more left-wing publications.
Now, maybe it’s because I’m just indie, and anything that smacks of consensus of opinion tends to bring me out in a rash. But I’m afraid this gleeful approbation of the gagging of Twitter had me reaching for my tinfoil hat.
I sense I am going to have to be careful here; please don’t misunderstand me. I find the behaviour of the Twitter’s self-appointed guardians of morality in this and many other issues thoroughly repugnant. I understand how the anonymity of the internet can occasionally promote a sort of mob mentality which provides a fascinating, if not particularly heartening, glimpse into the deepest darkest corners of human nature. I also am perfectly familiar with the concept of libel, and how damaging unfounded accusations can be for someone’s career and mental health.
But that doesn’t ever, ever mean that our international community’s forum for discussion of key issues shouldn’t be as free as humanly possible. We should be greeting this new precedent for hiring ridiculously pricey law firms to hold us to account for every stupid little thing we’ve sent out onto our Twitter timeline with at least a degree of hesitance.
Sympathize with the victims of the abuse, by all means, and perhaps view the prosecution of the more high-profile or virulent tweeters as a necessary evil. But approve the investigation of the 10,000-odd people, who, in a moment of idiocy, and genuinely believing the subject of their attacks was guilty of something terrible, jumped on the bandwagon? Even those who simply retweeted others’ comments, and who afterwards deleted the offending material? Never.
It is easy to forget, in the mass of uncensored, vitriolic rubbish that bombards the internet, that sites such as Twitter have an extremely important function to perform, especially when our press is monopolized by shady Australian businessmen and the odd Russian oligarch. The near perfect freedom of expression that the online world has brought is a valuable thing.
Even if it means that every abusive little bigot who never got enough attention from their parents has his own little platform from which to vomit forth his bile on the world, we should remember the phrase, “I do not agree with what you have to say, but I’ll defend to the death your right to say it.”
The Independent’s Grace Dent, in frankly worrying language, rather curtly dismissed the “frothy-mouthed freedom-of-speech defenders” who might oppose her views. Well, I’m sorry, but I reserve the right to froth at the mouth a little. In this matter, and this matter alone, better to be a stark raving lunatic than otherwise.

