The London Extinction Rebellion: does such protest actually have an impact?

Johnny Stocks

On 28th June 2016, I took part in a mass demonstration following the UK’s vote to leave the European Union. Thousands of Londoners, and Europeans alike, gathered in Trafalgar Square to walk down Whitehall to the Houses of Parliament. Protestors left the square, walked straight across Charing Cross, and filled the entirety of Whitehall all the way to Westminster.

There was a little more than a confused Jon Snow reporting from a balcony to mark the event, despite the chaos it caused through the heart of central London. Bus and Taxi drivers sat at their wheels, amazed, as a cosmopolitan crowd of demonstrators adorned in blue and gold ran before them. More than two years on, the futility of that event sinks in. We turned up, we marched and then we got the train home.

We turn up to feel good about ourselves – to feel useful. In reality, the results are now far more personal than political.

Two Saturdays ago, thousands of protestors descended on central London to make their voices heard in the midst of an international climate crisis. Following what The Guardian described as a ‘huge act of peaceful civil disobedience’, with thousands of protestors occupying five bridges across the Thames, eighty-five people were arrested.

Whilst most were arrested for obstructions under the Highways Act, the incident raises important questions, especially in light of the #RippedOff demonstrations here in Durham, about whether such protests can genuinely have a meaningful impact.

Protests raise awareness, but evidence suggests a 21st century demonstration struggles to do much more.

If there’s one thing to learn whilst we are young, it’s that “Nothing strengthens authority so much as silence.” This idea, associated with Leonardo da Vinci, is crucial in all walks of political and personal life, and bears an undeniable relevance in the fight against climate change.

However, whilst the heady idealism and neat packaging of this concept may inspire us, we also have to realise that Government, or any institution for that matter, only listens to the protests it wants to listen to. Political narratives are constructed in large by the powerful, with power growing out of ex through influence rather than numbers.

But it wasn’t always this way. A Google search for the most effective protests of History quickly shows us clear examples of heroic campaigning that brought about genuine change. The Boston Tea Party sparked the American Revolution. The 1963 March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom advocated the rights of African Americans and was a vital catalyst for the Civil Rights Acts of 1964. However, it’s hard to find good examples from more recent times.

Facebook can get us to a city square, but it can never replace genuine political activism.

Social Media has admittedly made such protests far easier to organise and grow to unprecedented scales, but it has also turned demonstrations into what The New Yorker describes as ‘social theatre’. We turn up to feel good about ourselves – to feel useful. In reality, the results are now far more personal than political.

Facebook can get us to a city square, but it can never replace genuine political activism.

Despite this, British artist Gavin Turk, who was arrested in last weekend’s Extinction Rebellion protest, said it was worth it. Direct action, for many, appears the only way to wake politicians up to the collective damage we are doing. Herein lies the issue. Protests raise awareness, but evidence suggests a 21st-century demonstration struggles to do much more.

But that’s not an issue. Awareness is crucial, and for many such demonstrations are the only chance for engagement, even if superficial, with politics and national governance. Politics can so often be a game for the influential, and whilst we say we have a Parliamentary democracy, the average citizen, in reality, will never have much influence. Thus, if we want a voice, we have to fight for it.

Image by Julia Hawkins via Flickr