The Liberal Tory?

David Davis MP was once one of the most important men in British politics: he was the one time front-runner for the Conservative leadership campaign, eventually losing out to David Cameron after a disastrous conference speech which he himself admits he should have prepared more thoroughly.

He eventually became shadow home secretary before his shock resignation in June, prompted by the government’s proposed plan to extend the police’s ability to detain without charge from 28 to 42 days.

I asked David, in the wake of his resignation, if he still believed he had made the right decision. He is firm in his assertion that the move was effective:

‘In the course of the last year we have seen 42 days collapse, not just be defeated, but collapse. It’s not coming back. We have seen ID cards get pushed back and back. We have seen the DNA database be pretty much knocked out and we have seen the government withdraw its bill on monitoring our communications. All those things have happened since June. I couldn’t actually have asked for a better set of outcomes.’

He answers with a categorical yes when asked if he would do the same thing again, although he is acutely aware of the arguments against his current position.

‘Of course some might say that it would have happened anyway or that it was unnecessary. I don’t agree, if I had thought that beforehand then I wouldn’t have done it.’

In fact, his opposition was not just to the 14 day extension of the police’s powers, but to lengthy imprisonment without charge in all its forms.

‘When 28 days was agreed, the government were trying to get 90 days through and I made a straight empirical decision: what can I win with?’ David advocates the admission of intercept evidence in court, with the aim of eventually reaching the American level of just 2 days imprisonment without charge.

He, surprisingly, does not oppose CCTV, but believes stronger measures should be put in place to ensure it is not misused:

‘I don’t mind CCTV so long as it is used solely for the purpose for which it’s legally designed and so long as there’s some recourse for people for whom it invades their privacy. We have had cases of CCTV cameras being switched on young women getting undressed in their bedrooms or used to maximise the parking revenues for the council. We have more CCTV cameras than the rest of the world and yet less convictions and we don’t have protections for people. It should be an imprisonable offence to misuse CCTV.’

David explains the level of public support, particularly from the student body, that he has received since June, and the by-election which swept him back to Westminster.

‘I’ve had well over 100 requests to go and speak in universities and colleges up and down the country and a huge blog response.’

Despite there being no scenes of outrage on the streets with people campaigning against the erosion of civil liberties, which one might expect, there is nevertheless, as he explains, a ‘ferocious’ student viewpoint being expressed over the internet.

‘This is not an age in which people take to the streets very easily, especially not in this weather. It’s interesting in political terms: normally Conservative interests and Conservative spokesmen tend not to have the greatest attraction to the under-30s let alone the under-25s yet this is probably the strongest single issue.’

It is a testament to Davis himself that this area of Conservative policy has moved the younger population. Articulate and affable, David has long been a hugely popular public figure and his departure from the shadow Cabinet has been bemoaned by some left-leaning thinkers and politicians who consider the Conservatives to be moving back to being dominated by old-Etonians.

In fact, Davis’ background belies his social Conservatism. Davis’ grandfather, whom he cites as a strong influence, was disinherited because he belonged to the Communist party and later led a hunger strike following the famous Jarrow March, which Communists were forbidden to attend.

David himself was born in York, though he soon moved to London with his mother and apparently terrifying step-father, whose solution to an incident in which five boys tried to beat young David up was to send him out to stand up for himself:

‘After a minute he came out and stopped the fight which was just as well really. I was terrified.’

A product of a grammar-school education, he failed his A-levels before joining the TA’s SAS branch to earn money to retake them and eventually go to Warwick University.

Some have questioned Davis’ true liberality in the past. His website is called ‘David Davis for Freedom’ and he is revered as a champion of civil liberties. Yet in the past he has expressed support, in theory, for capital punishment, though it would never come in his lifetime, even were he to be Home Secretary.

He has voted against lowering the age of consent for homosexuals to the same as that for heterosexuals and against the repeal of Section 28, which forbade homosexual relationships in schools. He stresses that there is no contradiction in his holding these various views:

‘The only commonality is Guardian readership. People have views which are about individual things which have little to do with each other. Just because one set of people have that package of views doesn’t mean there’s a consistency between them. The circumstances for capital punishment are things like genocide, serial murders where the evidence is absolutely overwhelming; not beyond reasonable doubt but just beyond doubt and you could do that with multiple forensic data and so on. It’s a pretty esoteric thing but it’s about people who are proven, absolutely proven to be evil.’

He is keen to stress that he is on the side of the innocent and that the presumption of innocence is vital to our law and society.

The closure of Guantanamo Bay, a place where the presumption of innocence seems long ago to have been forgotten, meets David’s broad approval, however he recognises its one-time necessity:

‘I didn’t object in the first year, because the other side of the conflict treated it as a war and it’s perfectly legitimate for both sides to treat it as a war and in wars people are locked up in prisoner of war camps. But it’s been seven years now, I don’t remember there being any prisoner of war camps in 1952 for the Second World War not even for those people tried for Nuremburg.’

Legality once again comes to the fore as he stresses the need for trials:

‘Obama’s going to have to go through a proper legal process and that’s what it should be. They should be tried.’

Obama’s presidency may not herald a change in the way Britain and the rest of the world views their own civil liberties, but it offers opportunities he claims, particularly in relation to the Muslim world, but also opportunities to do some of the ‘tough things, about Afghanistan for example’.

He is keen to stress his firm anti-terror stance and acknowledges he is ‘very tough on the actions you need to be tough on. If the defence of freedom was left to Guardian reading vegetarians then we’d all be in a sorry state today. Probably wouldn’t be speaking English either.’

It is this toughness, he claims, which gives Davis the platform from which he can legitimately champion civil liberties.

There is a confidence in his motives and actions and an acceptance of their bearing on his future. He has admitted in the past that he will most likely not be in the cabinet of a future Conservative government and is wary of the risk of becoming what he calls ‘a single-issue politician’.

‘It undermines the issue’ he explains, ‘not to mention myself. So for example I spent the summer studying Afghanistan and went there in the autumn. I came up with a set of proposals which, interestingly enough, today the Americans have pretty much adopted: sort out Karzai, increase troop levels and do something about the justice system so you can actually have an influence if you set your mind to it.’

Whatever your opinion on the erosion of civil liberties, the Iraq war and even capital punishment, it is refreshing to speak to a politician who is so candid and firm in his views and beliefs.

He uses the word ‘sacrifice’ regularly in reference to his resignation, despite claiming not to miss the bureaucracy and the incessant meetings which came with being on the shadow front bench.

Davis should be lauded for his stance and the vigour with which he defends it, and for having the courage to sacrifice his own political spotlight for an issue which, he believes, was being hurried through in the dark.

Factfile

Born
23rd December 1948

Place of Birth
York, England

Nationality
British

Education
University of Warwick,
London Business School,
Harvard University

Political Career
Member of Parliament for Boothferry
(1987 – 1997)
Member of Parliament for Haltemprice and Howden
(1997 – present)

Chairman of the Conservative Party
(September 2001 – July 2002)

Shadow Home Secretary
(November 2003 – June 2008)