The legacy of revolution leaves storm clouds looming over Egypt
Egypt’s first experiment with democracy has ended in disaster.
Mohamed Morsi, the country’s first democratically elected president, has been placed under house arrest by the military and replaced by an interim government, sworn in amid violent protests and bloodshed.
Without a doubt, the speed of change has been breath-taking. As the Egyptian army revelled in a groundswell of support among protesters in Tahrir Square, the Muslim Brotherhood were toppled in a matter of hours, their constitution in shreds.
Britain and the United States, meanwhile, have been keen to overlook the ugly collapse of President Morsi at the hands of the military. Instead, they’ve preferred to stress the need for stability in the most populous and strategically important nation in the Arab world.
In the midst of such unprecedented change, several questions are undoubtedly raised.
How did this come to pass? How could the people, after clamouring for a liberal democracy, wilfully push a democratically elected president out of office? And what, above all, does this mean for the future of Egypt?
From the moment that Mohamed Morsi took office, disputes have raged over the influence of the Muslim Brotherhood. In this sense, the latest round of political chaos comes as little surprise.
Morsi has spectacularly failed to deliver on his election promises, insecurity and violence still plague Egypt, whilst his moves to arrest journalists and override the judiciary had been compared to the days of Mubarak.
With the army deciding that Morsi had to go, emboldened by public support, they delivered an ultimatum threatening to remove him from power unless order was restored.
In the forty-eight hour period that followed, with the ransacking of the Cairo offices of the Muslim Brotherhood, the resignations of several government spokesmen and with rumours circulating that the army was set to take control, it became clear that the Morsi government was in its death throes.
Despite controversy over the role of the military, many Egyptians have openly celebrated this intervention after twelve months of mounting fears over Morsi’s Islamist agenda.
Rather than address these concerns, Morsi closed ranks, angering his liberal opponents and paralysing his leadership in the process. Western observers, particularly those who have always been squeamish about the rise of political Islam, have also quietly welcomed his fall from grace.
However, Morsi’s removal, after just one year in office, sets a dangerous precedent.
The fact that he was elected democratically has been treated as a mere technicality that can be accepted or rejected at will, with people now opting to place their trust in guns and sects rather than the democratic process of elections.
It is also clear that the Muslim Brotherhood will not go quietly, particularly after enduring eighty-five years of attempts to stamp them out as a political force.
Pro-Morsi protests have already erupted across Egypt, with several people killed and dozens injured after security forces opened fire on protesters in Cairo and Alexandria.
Although military chiefs have promised a swift transition towards democracy, the army has not shied away from packing the streets with troops, arresting political opponents and forcing a number of Islamic television stations to cease transmission.
The army has placed their faith in the Chief Justice, Adly Mansour, to serve as interim president. His appointment is hardly surprising given that the judiciary, under his leadership, has been a persistent thorn in the side of the Muslim Brotherhood.
Regardless of the circumstances surrounding military intervention, the army will remain outside of day-to-day affairs. But their actions have opened up a dangerous fault line between liberals and the supporters of a democratically elected Islamist government.
At the root of this turmoil is Morsi’s failure to address the economic crisis and reassert authority on the streets.
Economists predict that the economy faces the prospect of total collapse, despite being kept afloat with billions of dollars in aid from the Gulf States, which is primarily being used to provide food subsidies.
Even the United States appears to take the view that, in the case of Egypt, stability is currently of greater value than democracy.
With hugely significant strategic interests in the region, the United States is keen to continue supporting the Egyptian army with generous financial aid packages, estimated at around $1.3 billion annually, despite its role in toppling Egypt’s first democratically elected government.
Political commentators and many ordinary Egyptians seem to have expected too much.
They somehow hoped and believed that a country which has suffered from a total lack of coherent political institutions would be able to establish a stable democracy in a matter of months.
Whatever happens, the immediate outlook for Egypt does not look good.
It remains to be seen whether the Egyptian people, with their demands for civil liberties, will learn to organise themselves and campaign democratically alongside the Muslim Brotherhood.
The alternative is the continued pursuit of their slash and burn tactics that have pushed Egypt to the brink of anarchy.
Photographs: Jonathan Rashad, BanyanTree, M. Soli, Sherif9282

