The launch of PLT Marketplace is just embarrassing
By Holly Downes
PrettyLittleThing — the fast fashion superpower known for its bubblegum pink packaging, unicorn mascot, and cheap clothing — has taken customers by surprise earlier this month. Despite being renowned for its unethical practices, where it makes profit from items for as little as 8p during Black Friday, they recently launched PLT Marketplace which encourages customers to buy and sell second-hand clothing. Selecting the Love Island star, Indiyah Polack, to be their first PLT Marketplace ambassador, advertisements show her frolicking around in recycled outfits and urging viewers to join the ‘PLT loved movement’ in an attempt to create a sustainable future for PLT. But can PLT and sustainability ever really be compatible?
At face value, a marketplace is a good way to offset arguably the most damaging part of the fashion industry. Gaining the title for the world’s biggest polluter (swiftly after the oil industry), any attempt to wipe away this title is commendable. With demand growing by the day, especially due to the increasing popularity of fast fashion which sees trends come and go within a blink, production increases, and therefore pollution skyrockets — a trend which marketplaces attempt to slow down. Becoming places where people can make money from their neglected clothes, it has become a way to save and make extra money, and rid people of their guilty consciences for contributing to the current climate crisis.
PLT’s business model is classically unsustainable
Yet, my issue with PLT Marketplace lies not within the marketplace itself, but that a brand founded, built, and thriving on exploitation oversees a platform which attempts to oppose this. PLT’s business model is classically unsustainable. It makes profits by rapid production at low prices, all of which is only successful when workers are exploited and the cheapest, non-eco-friendly materials are used. So, whilst the company scores the lowest possible labour rating of ‘Very Poor’ and an environment rating of ‘Not Good Enough’, PLT Marketplace is plastered with the bold logo; ‘Re-sell. Re-wear. Re-cycle’. If that isn’t a laughable contradiction, I don’t know what is.
As if this project couldn’t get any worse, the introductory description of the marketplace just becomes embarrassing. Claiming that PLT Marketplace is designed to ‘extend the life of garments, breathe new life into pre-loved clothing, and help reduce waste with the impact of the environment front of mind’ just proves the hypocritical nature of PLT. The lives of their garments can never be ‘extended’ because they are made too cheaply. They couldn’t care less about the environment if they wanted to. Opting for planet-damaging polyester and separate plastic packaging for each item, with Greenpeace revealing that 89% of PLT’s clothing is made from new plastic, they truly are the perfect example of ‘cheap and cheerful’.
This project is just another case of greenwashing – when a brand plasters over problematic business models with a sparkling environmentally-friendly movement. Agreeing with the co-founder of Made Them, host of All the Small Things podcast, Venetia La Manna, wrote that ‘there are so many brilliant second-hand platforms that don’t support maker exploitation, please use them instead’ — a tweet that perfectly captures the irony of a PLT Marketplace. Stressing that we cannot have ethics without sustainability, where you cannot achieve one without the other, PLT need to address and change their business model before creating add-ons that attempt to disguise and contradict the very foundation of their business.
How can these clothes ‘breathe new life’ when they die after a couple of wears?
Furthermore, the plans for the marketplace seem rather impractical. It encourages people to list their ‘pre-loved’ PLT clothes, all of which are made from thin materials that don’t last more than a few washes before looking tacky. Fast-fashion pieces are designed to be worn until they become unfashionable, and with trends moving so fast, they aren’t designed for longevity, but brevity. So how can these clothes ‘breathe new life’ when they die after a couple of wears? How can PLT possibly make this marketplace work then the items listed are on the verge of disintegrating?
To me, it looks like PLT are exploiting the real use of marketplaces, using it as a tool to look like they are striving to become more sustainable, but instead using the profits gained from the project to fuel their unsustainable production lines. Rather than promoting other reselling apps such as Vinted and eBay, they design their own app and make even more money to produce even more fast-fashion clothes which all counteract the purpose of a marketplace. PLT are making it seem that they are trying to better their ways, but how can they ever really change when their brand survives on the very antithesis of ‘Re-sell. Re-wear. Re-cycle’?
PLT’s business model needs to be remodelled if they are ever to head towards a sustainable future, but something tells me that profits will always be more important over any respect for workers and the planet. So, I guess all I can say is, do better PrettyLittleThing.
Image: Jose Mizrahi via Unsplash

