The Labour Party and the independent group: the updates

Ellen Leafstedt

At a press conference on Monday, seven MPs announced their resignation from the Labour party in protest of Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership to form an alternative grouping. The Independent Group, composed of MPs Luciana Berger, Chuka Umunna, Chris Leslie, Angela Smith, Ann Coffey, Mike Gapes, and Gavin Shuker argued that under Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership, the Labour Party has “changed beyond recognition”. The breakaway is the largest in the Labour Party’s history since the ‘gang of four’ quit to form the Social Democratic Party in 1981.

Under Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership, the Labour Party has “changed beyond recognition”

The MPs drew on themes such as party in-fighting, Brexit, and institutional bigotry in their resignation speeches. People’s Vote advocate Chuka Umunna, regarded as the “ringleader” of the group, has expressed hopes a new party would be created by the end of the year.  

Almost all are commonly associated with the ‘Blairite’ wing of the Labour Party

Luciana Berger MP, a Jewish woman herself, said her departure from the Party was motivated by its institutional anti-Semitism. Berger had been targeted with death threats and abuse on social media. The considerable harassment meant she had to be escorted by police to last year’s Labour Conference.

Out of the seven MPs, almost all are commonly associated with the ‘Blairite’ wing of the Labour Party, representing policy stances closer to the centre than Corbyn and the Momentum movement that propelled him to power.

The group got off to an awkward start

Critics of the group have denounced the MPs avoidance of a by-election. While some of the MPs’ constituencies will likely be supportive of the split, such as Chuka Umunna’s constituency of Streatham, others are in danger of losing their seats in traditional Labour areas. Luciana Berger, Angela Smith, and Chris Leslie, whose vocal criticisms of Jeremy Corbyn and the “intolerant hard left” have earned them reproach in their constituencies, faced possible deselection before their departure from the party and might not survive a by-election if loyalist Labour candidates were to run against them.

The group got off to an awkward start. Angela Smith made headlines in a less than pleasant manner after being invited on BBC 2’s Politics Live show to discuss her new independent status. The MP for Penistone and Stocksbridge was discussing racism experienced by BAME women and Jews when she appeared to say: “it’s not just about being black or a funny tinge…”.

Smith apologised for her comments in a video posted on Twitter, saying: “It’s not what I am. I am committed to fighting racism wherever I find it in our society.”

Solidarity with British Jews, who “suffered terrible abuse from supporters of the Labour leadership”

MP for Enfield North Joan Ryan has become the eighth member of the Independent Group. In a Twitter announcement Tuesday evening, Ryan expressed her regret for departing the Party after four decades and her solidarity with British Jews, who “suffered terrible abuse from supporters of the Labour leadership”.

The question remains as to whether yet more MPs from Labour or another party will join the Independent Group. A Buzzfeed News report revealed that the breakaway was originally meant to involve up to thirty Labour MPs, but that clashes of personalities and disagreements over goals and logistics of timing kept most from executing the final plan.

Labour has been plagued with divisions between its leftist and centrist wings

The Independent Group’s move comes at a time when Labour has been plagued with divisions between its leftist and centrist wings. Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn has been confronted with sustained criticism within the party over his uncertain stance on Brexit. While polls show 90% of Labour members would vote to remain in a second EU referendum, Corbyn reasons that he represents the broader swathe of Labour voters, over 40% of whom voted to leave in 2016.

The Labour Party leader faces another challenge in a series of anti-Semitism scandals, which Luciana Berger’s resignation has brought back to the fore. Last August, accusations against Corbyn over anti-Semitism escalated after the emergence of pictures showing him laying a wreath in honour of individuals associated with the Munich Olympic massacre of Israeli Jewish athletes. Corbyn said of the controversy: “I was present at that wreath-laying, I don’t think I was actually involved in it.”

Several top Labour figures have acknowledged the problems drawn upon by the Independent Group amid warnings of more MPs departing. Shadow Chancellor John McDonnell announced “a massive listening exercise” to come, while Deputy Labour leader Tom Watson MP denounced anti-Semitism in the party, and said the departure of MPs represented a test for Labour: “I fear now that unless we change, we may see more days like this.”

Jeremy Corbyn did not address the accusations of anti-Semitism

Jeremy Corbyn did not address the accusations of anti-Semitism and anti-EU sentiments levied against him by the resigning MPs. In a series of tweets, he expressed his disappointment with the seven MPs and praised Labour’s wider platform “for the many not the few”.

In other news Derek Hatton is reported to have re-joined the Labour Party 34 years after his expulsion. The former Trotskyist said Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership led him to re-apply for membership.

Hatton, who was ejected from the Party for his membership in the far-left Militant faction, commented on the Independent Group: “For them to leave now is at best hypocritical and at worst dishonest.”

Photo Credits: UK Parliament via Wikimedia Commons