The KP debate part II: Pietersen was a leech not a lion
In 1985 Billy Ocean sang “when the going gets tough, the tough get going”. If only a five-year-old Kevin Pietersen had listened.
The vast majority of observers have been shocked and dismayed at the decision to end Pietersen’s career, citing his remarkable statistics to question the logic of the ECB’s decision. On paper, Pietersen was a great of the English game; you don’t score over 8,000 test runs without being half-decent.
However, what many people fail to see is that the issue surrounding Kevin Pietersen cannot be solved using statistics. In fact, the main point of this argument is something that cannot be identified by any facts at all – it is about the effect that Pietersen had on the England dressing room, something which is unquantifiable.
The mood of a dressing room is important in any sport, but in cricket especially due to the long periods of time that you are there with your teammates – often for days on end.
There is a scale which defines the impact you have on a dressing room; at one end there are the lions, those players which roar you through when you’re winning or losing.
And then at the other end of the spectrum there are the leeches, the players who roll along in the good times, but suck the life and soul out of the group during the difficult periods.
If the rumours surrounding KP are true, then he must be considered a dressing room leech. The two major incidents that he has been controversially involved in were the South African texting farce, when he told England’s opponents how to best bowl at his own captain, Andrew Strauss.
This came at a time when England were struggling to retain their number one ranking, and were on a downward curve. The second came this winter in the painful Ashes tour which without question was a disaster for the side.
England are at an all-time low, and what they need now is a group of lions; they need players who will go out and play the best they possibly can day in-day out.
What is not needed is a player like Pietersen, who, despite having all the talent one could possibly need, often played, you felt, not at his very best and didn’t apply himself fully to the job at hand.
The one figure we can’t quantify is the effect that Pietersen’s character had on his fellow teammates. If his presence resulted in other players not being able to play at their very best, then the ECB would have had no choice but to remove him.
It may have been harsh to remove him from the picture completely, however, in nine years of international cricket, how much has his character changed? And do the ECB think there is any chance of him turning his attitude around?
Whatever you make of his remarkable talent, one thing is for sure: England need to proceed with a team of eleven lions- they cannot afford to carry any leeches with them anymore.
It is a great shame that we will never see KP on the international stage again, but his loss could well be England’s gain.
Want to respond to the KP debate? Tweet us @palatiSPORT
Photographs: Rae Allen and Stephen Caffull


