The Iowa Caucus: Sanders and Cruz Send Shockwaves through America

By Joe Slater

A year ago, the headline ‘Ted Cruz upsets Donald Trump in GOP race’ would have passed as a joke from the Onion. Instead, the morning after the 2016 Iowa caucuses, it was on the front page of the Washington Post. The next story, ‘Clinton, Sanders in virtual tie’, would have seemed just as unlikely. After the months of campaigning, the debating, the polling, and the punditry, Democrat and Republican voters finally got the chance to have their say.

With the help of an extensive campaign organisation, the support of a sizeable evangelical community, and perhaps a few late mistakes from his opponents, Texas Senator Ted Cruz took 27% of the vote, and victory in the first in the nation Iowa Republican caucuses. The Democratic race finished with frontrunner Hillary Clinton just a few votes ahead of self-described ‘democratic socialist’ Bernie Sanders. Iowa, the first state to vote in this drawn out nomination process, has always had an oversized impact. It was in Iowa that Barack Obama established his candidacy in 2008; in 2016, the small mid-western state has once again thrown the nomination process into chaos.

There is no doubt that success in Iowa comes down to playing the expectations game as much as actually winning votes. That’s how 24% of Iowans caucusing for a businessman with no elected experience, who called the people of that state ‘stupid’ and who has forged his campaign on building a wall on the Mexican border, is being deemed a disappointment. After all the controversy and discussion, all the bragging about how much ‘winning’ he was going to do for America, Donald Trump lost. Trump was very nearly pushed into third place by a resurgent Marco Rubio. It’s tricky to say whether Trump’s poll numbers had always been artificially inflated, or whether his lack of spending on campaign infrastructure led to his loss. Either way, this was a bad night for the businessman.

If Trump failed by finishing second then Florida Senator Marco Rubio somehow won by finishing third. Surging in the final days before polling, Rubio’s unexpectedly high result is a huge momentum builder, the man widely seen as the likely nominee due to his appeal to establishment Republicans, has finally cemented himself in the eyes of Republican voters. The actual winner of the caucuses, Ted Cruz, also has renewed momentum; he is as disliked as Trump by party leaders and will look to build on his victory with further success in the southern Republican heartlands.

The Republican race isn’t the only one witnessing anti-establishment backlash. At the start of December, Hillary Clinton led Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders by as much as 32%, on caucus night the two candidates tied on 50%. That Hillary Clinton, widely perceived as the most unbeatable candidate in decades, could only scrape a win against a 74-year-old socialist, suggests the Democrat revolt is in full flow. The divide is stark and extensive. 84% of caucus-goers under the age of 30 supported Sanders while Clinton took 69% of those 65 and older. This is not simply a generational split, Sanders dominated amongst voters who saw ‘honesty’ as the most important facet of a candidate. Despite these problems and the setback in Iowa, Clinton remains in control of the race. Sanders always seemed likely to do well in white, liberal states like Iowa and the next stop, New Hampshire. When the race opens up to more diverse areas in the south, and on the west coast, she is likely to take a commanding lead. After Iowa though, there can be no doubt that Democrat voters are as restless as their Republican counterparts.

After Iowa, both parties are in this race for the long haul. Bernie Sanders and his supporters will be buoyed by their early success, and will undoubtedly drag out the nomination into the spring. For Republicans the path is less clear. There are signs that their contest will evolve into a 3-way battle, with the party establishment coalescing around Marco Rubio, the right wing base supporting Ted Cruz, and the populist centre backing Donald Trump. The result of this formation is anybody’s guess, although history tells us that the party usually decides. Iowa, then, has set the stage, between establishment and grassroots, between young and old, between populist and elitist; and the race has only just begun.

Photograph: Phil Roeder via Flickr