The Indigo Canon: ‘BoJack Horseman’, and taking responsibility for who you are

By Vadim Goss

*Spoilers*

“You are all the things that are wrong with you. It’s not the alcohol, or the drugs, or any of the shitty things that happened to you in your career, or when you were a kid, it’s you… alright. It’s you.” This is what Todd says to BoJack in the final straw of their relationship. Todd is BoJack’s best friend. BoJack has left Todd with no choice.

BoJack Horseman was one of the first shows Netflix ever commissioned; it was their first big success. It was a statement of intent by the streaming service that they were not just here to exist alongside the major networks, but they were going to be the major network. Instead of seeking to merely fill an 8pm timeslot on a Thursday night, they were going to carve out their own timeslot – with edgy, boundary-breaking content, free from the family-friendly restrictions of network television. Indeed, the show often parodies this feel-good sterilisation of American television.

The show navigates around one central question: Is BoJack Horseman a good person?

BoJack became a household name in the 90s sitcom Horsin’ Around, in which he becomes a father to 3 orphans and must learn how to take care of them. And of course it is them who, in the end, take care of him. In the scenes we see of Horsin’ Around, BoJack plays more or less himself, but a version of himself for when the cameras are rolling. Ideally, BoJack’s character in Horsin’ Around is the BoJack he would like to be, and who he cannot be. For BoJack Horseman is a show about who a person is when the cameras are off, when there is no script, when there is no audience. And so what begins as a goofy albeit self-aware show about Hollywood and anthropomorphic animals, as a conventional sitcom in which the status quo is retained and the protagonist is always the hero – no matter how unheroic they may be – quickly becomes a subversion to its own genre, and descends into a story about waning stardom, addiction, anxiety, depression, death, and most significantly, the need to change.  

The show navigates around one central question: Is BoJack Horseman a good person? From there it reaches the stars. For what is a good person? Is it the belief that one is good? Or in the actions that define good? And purely from the actions he commits one must say he is not. For BoJack does some truly terrible things. And as Diane, the show’s moral compass, says to BoJack, “all you are is just the things that you do.” So BoJack consists of many awful things. But is he not altogether irredeemable? Certainly at the start, this is all that BoJack wants. To be forgiven, and for people to understand why he deserves to be forgiven. But whether BoJack is sorry is another thing altogether. Yes, he certainly feels regret, and he certainly wants to be absolved, but yet true repentance is rendered in change. BoJack wants to be forgiven in order to be excused of this responsibility. Ultimately, he wants to be forgiven so he does not have to forgive himself.

To feel truly ‘good’ about yourself is to understand that the question of whether you are a good person is one too confining and narrowing

For others to merely tell you that ‘you are a good person’ or to forgive someone without merit, is, in the words of BoJack’s former best-friend and Horsin’ Around showrunner Herb Kazzaz, a “prop so you can feel better.” It is medicinal but artificial. And Herb does not forgive BoJack for what he did to him. He refuses to give him that drug. To deserve to be forgiven one must first truly feel the sting of being sorry and change. And this is where BoJack Horseman offers its simplest and greatest lesson (and the show is in the rarest category of art in which it actually offers transformative lessons): to feel truly ‘good’ about yourself is to understand that the question of whether you are a good person is one too confining and narrowing. To try and feel ‘good’, one must rid oneself of the question entirely. That to feel ‘good’, we must gain the power and strength to forgive ourselves even if others will not, and to change for the better as a result. The show acknowledges that this is not an easy thing to do. But the more you try, the easier it gets. “But you got to do it everyday. That’s the hard part. But it does get easier.”

Happiness in BoJack Horseman philosophy comes in the defeat of this struggle. And the show evolves in the rejection of the aforementioned question in exchange for another: Does BoJack change? To which the answer lies in intersection. He can change; he has the capacity to be happy. The show then ends with a choice. That you can choose, between how “life’s a bitch and then you die,” but that “sometimes life’s a bitch and then you keep living.” And if, in death, as is shown in ‘A View From Halfway Down’ (the show’s best episode), “there is no other side,” then life must be rewarded with the latter choice. The right choice.

Image: superawesomevectors via DeviantArt