The Importance of Being Earnest review: ‘uplifting and delightful’

By Chris Vidler

There aren’t many productions on the Durham theatre scene that are performed in the fresh air of the outdoors. There are even less that draw you in with the promise of a complimentary glass of prosecco; a chance to enjoy the tranquillity of the university’s botanic garden; and the opportunity to laugh the evening away on a blanket or picnic bench. Aidan’s College Theatre’s production of The Importance of Being Earnest did just that, and offered plenty of high quality acting to boot. Credit goes to director Becky Wilson and her production team for taking Oscar Wilde’s well-known play and adding touches of individuality that made the whole evening a rather uplifting and delightful experience.

I could highlight every one of the nine-strong cast for some particular aspect that really made this production stand out. The sassy, matriarchal assertiveness of Poppy Sparrow’s Lady Bracknell was certainly one of the driving forces of the performance, while the dynamic facial expressions and reactions of actors such as Wilf Wort (Algernon) and Angharad Phillips (Gwendolen) kept the energy going throughout. Even the contrasting butlering styles of Zac Tiplady (Lane) and Ram Gupta (Merriman) provided brief moments of physical comedy that I hadn’t expected from this kind of production. If nothing else, I feel Wort’s commitment to soldiering on through his lines whilst visibly stuffing his face with sandwiches and muffins was nothing short of admirable.

The show was definitely at its strongest when instances of perfect comedic timing and confident delivery brought out the humour in Wilde’s dialogue, with simple lines such as “I can hardly eat muffins in an agitated manner” frequently leaving the audience in stitches. Particular highlights included the ‘interrogation’ scene between Lady Bracknell and Jack Worthing, which Sparrow and Alex Marshall played to tremendous comic effect. A similarly entertaining moment emerged during Gwendolen and Cecily’s apparent realisation that they are both engaged to the same man. For this, Phillips and Katie O’Toole ended up trading a series of utterly acerbic exchanges whilst striving to maintain a quintessentially English sense of restraint, resulting in a passive-aggressive face-off that was just as dramatically compelling as it was hilarious to watch.

The decision to stage the play outdoors was an especially bold one given recent changes in the weather. However, the sun chose to shine and it ultimately paid off, creating an idyllic atmosphere that fitted the play’s quaint Victorian setting. Particularly innovative was the use of two separate spaces within the botanic garden to create two separate ‘stages’ – one section enclosed by hedges representing Algernon’s flat, with another more open area serving as the garden of Jack’s manor house in the countryside. Even more innovative was the use of cake and cucumber sandwiches to entice audience members from one location to another (the offer of a second glass of prosecco would no doubt have been the height of innovation).

Nevertheless, part of me felt that the unique space could have been used to more effect, and I occasionally questioned the blocking of certain scenes. During some of their more intimate discussions, Wort and O’Toole seemed intent on hiding away as far upstage from the audience as possible, concealing themselves behind chairs and tables as if they were genuinely trying to avoid being overheard by anyone. The two actors had an unfortunate habit of speaking somewhat quietly or hastily at times, meaning some lines were regrettably lost among the summer evening’s background noise of gusts of wind, birdsong and the occasional intrusive police siren.

Indeed, my (admittedly minor) criticisms mainly concern the delivery of lines, some of which were directed upstage with backs to the audience, or seemingly just uttered to other characters as if there wasn’t even an audience present. There were also a few slightly noticeable line slips and cases of actors unintentionally cutting across one another. The latter in particular though is entirely forgivable, given that the production was apparently put together in a mere couple of days. In fact, it’s actually laudable that the actors were able to learn and bring such a substantial script to life so quickly, and I highly commend the cast and production team for creating a piece of theatre of this calibre within such a short space of time.

Overall, ACT’s production was a pleasant way to pass the time at the end of the academic year, and I can’t help thinking that in some ways it embodies the ‘Durham experience’ as a whole. Quirky, humorous encounters, an abundance of formal dress, the fresh air of the countryside on your doorstep, and, of course, never a missed opportunity to enjoy a glass of bubbly – sounds familiar, in all earnest.

Photograph: Sam Harrison