The History of the Tyne-Wear derby

By Jennifer Bailey

The Black Cats and the Magpies. The Mackems and the Geordies. 2 Cities. 12 miles apart. Yet so far. 

As a student at a northern university, you must have heard about the infamous rivalry between the two football clubs that dominate the region. If not, you should by now! In the wake of Sunderland’s 3-0 defeat to Newcastle on derby day last month, I have decided to delve a little deeper into this long-running dispute between the neighbouring cities.

Whilst the ‘Tyne-wear’/ ‘Wear-Tyne’ derby has made headlines for decades with riots, arrests, and football hooliganism, the turmoil between the two cities predates the beloved game in a conflict that has divided the people of the northeast for more than three centuries. As with most conflicts, there is usually a deep-rooted historical, economic, or political factor at the heart of the matter, and this is certainly the case concerning Sunderland vs Newcastle. 

In the late 16th and early 17th century, hostility began to surface in the cities of Sunderland and Newcastle. At the time, King Charles I unwaveringly awarded the East of England Coal Trade Rights to the Newcastle merchants, causing redundancy for Wearside coal industry traders. Coal mines and shipyards were Sunderland’s biggest source of income and dwindling trade left many working-class men without jobs, struggling to provide for their families, and some even died as a result! However, the conflict is well known to have originally begun with the breakout of the First of three English Civil Wars (1642-1651). Sunderland and Newcastle found themselves on either side of the Royalist-Parliamentarian divide with Sunderland taking the side of Oliver Cromwell’s government (due to trading inequalities); whilst Newcastle’s loyalty remained with the monarchy which gave them the upper hand in trading. 

In the late 16th and early 17th century, hostility began to surface in the cities of Sunderland and Newcastle

Following the Battle of Boldon Hill (1644), the once thriving city of Newcastle was invaded by and therefore occupied by the Scots, which led to a short-lived superior position for Sunderland. This day-long battle consisted of a loyal army from Newcastle and County Durham, who gathered to feud against an anti-monarchist Sunderland and Scottish army. After the battle, Newcastle was then used as a republican military base for the remainder of the war. By 1662, following the restoration of the monarchy, Newcastle successfully lobbied the government to increase the levy on a chaldron of Sunderland coal, which overturned any meaningful Wearside advantage in the coal trade. This political divide escalated to a war of economic power and rights over the coal industry, as well as an ongoing battle for equality and superiority of either city. 

Later, the emergence of the industrial revolution (1760-1840), and ongoing economic competition between the two cities caused further upheaval with the introduction of non-labour occupations and sporting culture. The working-class men of these northeast industrial regions found social identity and a collective culture upon going to watch football matches on a weekend with their ‘mates.’ What started as a way of unwinding after a busy week, soon turned into a religion for these men and the weekly rituals of matchday viewing and heavy drinking began. The first meeting of the two sides took place in 1883 with their first competitive match being an FA Cup tie (in 1888) which saw Sunderland win 2-0 over Newcastle. Since then, the decline of the coal mining and shipbuilding industries during the 20th century meant football became the new object of division between the ever-feuding regions and their populations. 

 Throughout this time, fans united in their collective support for their beloved team side and the Mackem/Geordie divide became evermore engrained in the souls of the men watching – and the generations who followed them. Perhaps it is the strong working-class culture of the northeast which makes the supporters of these clubs so well-known for their passion and dedication on matchdays and beyond. Or maybe it is the centuries-old rivalry spurring them on! Nevertheless, it can be argued that Sunderland and Newcastle supporters are amongst the most loyal supporters in England. 

The decline of the coal mining and shipbuilding industries during the 20th century meant football became the new object of division

Whilst many supporters nowadays describe the rivalry as ‘neighbourly’ or ‘friendly banter’ in social circles and within the workplace, it is evident that disputes at games were (and still are) a way of men being able to demonstrate their masculinity and create identity in a world constantly evolving through social change. In northern cities where the stereotypical man was associated with strength, grit, power, labour work and the presence of dominant masculinity, the loss of the coal mines and shipyards came as a major blow to unemployment rates and job satisfaction. Therefore, the introduction of pre- and post-match disputes (also known as ‘football hooliganism’) created a way for men to prove their masculinity amidst a time of economic uncertainty and the ongoing fight for the superiority of one city over another. 

In modern times, it is fair to say that this centuries-old dispute has become more of a novelty than a true vendetta. However, it has been kept alive through traditions and local societal norms of behaviour at the Tyne-Wear derby matches.  From pitch invaders to city centre clashes, these teams have an undeniably loyal following and dedicated season ticket holders. Whether it is Sunderland’s beloved Roker Park stadium (home to their 1973 FA Cup win); their current Stadium of Light; or Newcastle’s St James’ Park, all supporters have a club where they feel a sense of collective belonging which you could say is the reason football unites more people than it divides!

Image: James Taylor