The greatest alternative love stories
The greatest love stories ever told. The list would undoubtedly be inundated with the classics. The brooding, dominating, speechless man and the headstrong girl who finally realises that she loves, not hates him: Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights, her sister Charlotte’s Jane Eyre, Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice. The ‘doomed affair’ that punishes women for their inability to repress their sexuality: Tolstoy’s Anna Karenina, Flaubert’s Madame Bovary. “Star-cross’d” soulmates forced to split forever: Boris Pasternak’s Doctor Zhivago, and the original love story Romeo and Juliet.
Undeniably, these are classics for a reason: they are fantastic, timeless reads. The fairytale for the current generation, Stephanie Meyer’s Twilight series, arguably employs the recognised character tropes in Edward Cullen of Mr Rochester’s dark secrecy, or Heathcliff’s subdued violence because they appeal to something timeless within ourselves.
Yet do these novels, so well known and so well-loved, really ever portray real love, or are they escapist fantasies, constructed to manipulate our emotions and provide temporary relief from the genuine troubles of life? And what about the men out there? I would like to propose a new list, which may not be the ‘greatest’, and is in no way complete, but if you read them, might just give you that thunderbolt moment that could save your relationship.
If you’ve never told them how you feel…
The Remains of the Day – Kazuo Ishiguro
Ishiguro’s Booker Prize winner is more of a how-not-to, demonstrating how it could all just pass you by. It follows the story of Stephens, a butler in the post-war era about to embark upon new employment whose present is tied up in his lost past. The novel is beautifully written, heart-breakingly showing a man’s internal emotional struggle in conflict with his moral values, and his painful decision to never let his passion ripple the smooth surface of his dignified life.
If you want a man’s opinion…
High Fidelity – Nick Hornby
Hornby’s debut novel caused an absolute sensation as we suddenly realised that the modern male psyche, with all its doubts, anxieties, hopes and imperfections, had never been properly explored. What an amazing oversight, but what an opportunity for a fantastic novel. Hornby’s work is enfused with the eccentricities of the male idiom, obsessive over music; the protagonist runs a record store, and totally recognisable. Truly hilarious, it’ll have you lolling your head off. A great one for the men out there that are sick of Twilight, and for the girls that don’t quite get their boyfriends.
If you can’t let go…
The Accidental – Ali Smith
Easily my favourite book on this list, and ideal not just for relationships that you’re holding on to, but a whole load of physical, mental and emotional weight that won’t shift. Winner of the Whitbread novel award and shortlisted for the Booker Prize and Orange Prize, it tells the story of a disjointed family on holiday in Norfolk who are visited by a woman named Amber that shakes them roughly out of their banal existence. Gorgeously written, and guaranteed to make you want to spring clean your life.
If you’re in a long distance relationship…
The Time Traveller’s Wife – Audrey Niffenegger
OK, so you probably haven’t been separated by different time periods, but Niffenegger’s novel definitely deals with the pain of being away from your loved one. The novel’s greatest success is its believability, you’ll find yourself thinking you might have time-travelled upon waking up after a particularly heavy night out. Whilst its theme is Wellsian, its structure is original, cleverly using its limitations (as in the Grandfather paradox – you can’t go back in time and kill your Grandfather) to dramatic effect, adding suspense and mystery to the central classic love story. A trimph of the love between true soulmates over the distance that parts them.
If you want all of these and more…
Essays in Love – Alain de Botton
This novel, written by writer, presenter and philosopher Alain de Botton, is highly innovative in its form and style; simultaneously a novel with chronological storyline, an exercise in practical philosophy, (i.e. using it in everyday life to solve problems), and a psychological analysis of human behaviour in relationships. Ideal for anyone and everyone, as it’s highly accessible
