The Great British Bake Off: we don’t have time for this

By Geeks Teh
Last week, Nadiya Hussain, a British Muslim of Bangladeshi origin, achieved what pundits would call a landslide victory on BBC One’s The Great British Bake Off. Her confections shone far above those of runner-ups Tamal and Ian, and left my housemates and I ravenously hungry.
I am a devout Liberal. Whilst I am proud that liberalism has always been championing the cause for a more compassionate and politically correct society, I abhor the ‘liberal’ factions that promote paranoid compulsion for political correctness. If not for our Beveridge-induced obsession with political correctness, why else would the winner of a frankly uninspiring baking show attract commentary from The Telegraph, the Daily Mail, The Independent, and The Guardian?
This is, of course, neither a new nor rare obsession. Our phobia of giving the impression that we show unjustifiable bias has led to bloody conflict, ludicrous media campaigns and suppression of free speech. People of all political and religious persuasions are sucked into this ridiculous game – both the left and the right, and the liberal and conservative. While the BBC is a fantastic medium in spreading wholesome and moderate messages, I doubt it deliberately chisels political correctness in each and every programme produced.
I find it difficult to be convinced that Nadiya Hussain won for any reason other than being a better baker than any of the eleven other contestants (according to Mary Berry and Paul Hollywood). It is frankly ludicrous that Amanda Platell has suggested in the Daily Mail that Flora Shedden could have saved herself from elimination by baking a chocolate mosque. I can scant imagine Mary Berry gushing with tears of gratitude at Flora’s political correctness, while asphyxiating from the unpalatability of this correctness. While racist attitudes affect an unacceptable proportion of people, very little is achieved by analysing the result of a baking programme.
Far less is achieved by analysing the political agenda of Nadiya’s confections, or the motives of those dissatisfied with Nadiya’s victory. Nadiya baked a gorgeous wedding cake. Yes, the jewellery-encrusted wedding cake bridged two cultures very well. But was this done for any reason other than that these two cultures probably mean the world to Nadiya? More importantly, does it matter if that’s the case?
The left’s suspicion of the right’s racism and the liberals’ cynicism towards the conservatives is even more putrid considering how it imposes on one’s right to free speech. Supporters of Tamal and Ian would no doubt have been displeased by the outcome. Yet, (and this particularly concerns Ian’s supporters, obviously), it is not racist to not want Nadiya to win. Their supporters should be at liberty to present their viewpoint without fear of being labelled racist.
I do not, of course, intend to slight the dangers of racial bias. No doubt, some of the dissent against Nadiya’s victory was overtly racist. But we should not waste precious time and effort trying to decipher if there are such overtones in others’ criticisms. Rather, we should focus efforts on reiterating that Nadiya most probably won through merit. I realise, however, that my point is far too easy to be countered. Racism plagues far too many people, sometimes without them being aware of their malarkey. The findings of the BBC’s exemplar documentary last week – ‘Is Britain Racist?’ – show that years of exposure to the wise words of Tupac and the Daily Mail have taken their toll on people who would otherwise bite their thumb at racial prejudice. Yet, our time is far better spent addressing incidents where the outcomes were tangibly affected by prejudice.
How have we become so cynical so that a baking show is heralded as the benchmark for equality by some, and cited as a threat to British values by others? Where did we go so wrong? Imagine the headlines if I won the Great British Bake Off: ‘Shock and awe as fans demand inquiry into hygiene standards of Chinese Bake Off winner’?
Image: Samantha Beddoes via Flickr
