The government introduces a new migration returns agreement with France
By Tara Cartwright-Terry
Under pressure from Reform Leader, Nigel Farage, Labour’s ‘one in, one out’ policy was implemented in September. Agreed jointly by the British and French governments, the scheme has seen the acceptance of 57 migrants into the UK and the removal of 94 migrants so far. This policy allows the government to swiftly remove migrants to the EU for the first time since the UK left the Dublin System: an EU regulation whereby asylum applications are processed by the first county the applicant arrives in. With the government attempting to deter the use of small boats, any migrant who arrives illegally will have their claim treated as “inadmissible.” According to the rules of the scheme, they will be returned to France and be told to register their application from there.
The Refugee Council said “it is not an obviously unworkable policy like the Rwanda scheme”, however, they expressed “serious concerns” about how it will work in practice. Fears are circulating that victims of torture and trafficking will not be adequately protected or heard. This includes a man who returned to the UK by small boat less than a month after his initial removal, reporting that he has been a victim of modern slavery.
Lawyer Lionel Crusoé has suggested there is a failure to “sufficiently respect the principle of human dignity”
Last month, an appeal was presented to the French Council of State, the highest administrative court, against ‘one in, one out’. The appeal argues that the policy does not fairly consider the circumstances of each applicant – lawyer Lionel Crusoé has suggested there is a failure to “sufficiently respect the principle of human dignity.” The case, brought by 17 organisations linked to protecting Human Rights, claimed that the treaty should have been presented to the French Parliament for ratification.
This deal is part of a wider government push to “disrupt the business model” of illegal smuggling gangs to reduce dangerous channel crossings which have caused 20 deaths so far in 2025. The gangs are accused by critics of being armed and violent, exploiting migrants’ desperation, and completely disregarding safety.
The new “taxi boat” method has been particularly concerning to authorities. The boat, attempting to avoid French police on the beach, will remain in the water, requiring passengers to wade into the sea to board – a system labelled as chaotic by critics. Gangs have increased the number of migrants per boat, from an average of 13 in 2020, to 53 in 2024; leading to an increase of fatalities by overcrowding and crushing.
Gangs have increased the number of migrants per boat… leading to an increase of fatalities by overcrowding and crushing
French authorities are currently waiting for permission to deploy a new tactic of intercepting boats within 300 metres of land – a development that requires a reinterpretation of maritime law. The British government, meanwhile, is attempting to tackle gangs’ use of social media to advertise crossings. The Home Office has reported that 80% of migrants arriving in small boards used social media during their journey. The Home Affairs Committee is currently holding a series of hearings on small boat crossings, the first of which was last month where Rob Jones, Head of the Border Policing Command at the National Crime Agency (NCA) addressed the issue, promising that new efforts to track the users behind these accounts are taking place ‘at scale’. In the last year, 8000 accounts run by illegal smuggling gangs were removed while the gangs behind them remained undiscovered. Jones described this prior response as ‘whack-a-mole’ but confirmed that the NCA would be prioritising social media usage as one of its five main lines of effort.
In an attempt to engage potential clients, smugglers have been found to post disguised adverts online. Offers include £12,000 “package deals” marketed by Albanian smugglers, falsely promising accommodation and employment upon arrival. Advertising illegal channel crossings online is set to be made an offence under the government’s proposed Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Bill. Border Security Commander, Martin Hewitt, said, ‘One of the things we are doing in the Kurdistan region of Iraq, in Albania, and in Vietnam is deterrent comms: communications to counter the narrative that the smugglers are providing.’ The strategy is still developing, however, critics have suggested that it appears feeble in the face of conflict, famine, climate change and corruption which force people to seek safety elsewhere.
Image credit: US Coast Guard via Wikimedia Commons

