The Golden Age: who was it really for?

By Anna Hebb

For many, old Hollywood is remembered as one of the ‘golden’ times of cinema. To some degree, this seems justified: vibrant colour technology displaced traditional black and white films, talking pictures superseded silent movies, and the rise of major motion picture companies led to greater investment in the production and distribution of film. Yet while these technological and business advances undoubtedly revolutionised spectator experience, privileging viewers with a visually rich and audible atmosphere that targeted the senses and thus facilitated total psychological immersion, the term ‘golden’ refuses to account for those beyond the audience, whose experience of this era was far from favourable. 

Colour technology – golden or ghastly?

The advent of colour technology in 1928 marked a pivotal transition in the history of filmmaking. It brought lifelike colour to motion pictures and in doing so enabled a form of immersive visuality for spectators and greater artistic autonomy for filmmakers. Colour technology became a distinguishable feature of old Hollywood films – The Wizard Of Oz and Gone With The Wind best exemplify this with their full colour palette. We remember the hauntingly distinctive green that characterises the Wicked Witch of the East and the rosy cheeks and auburn pigtails that mark our beloved protagonist Dorothy. Yet the colour technology that gifted us with immersive thrill simultaneously served as the cause of discomfort for actors behind-the-scenes.

With its elaborate three-strip process, shooting in colour was incredibly time-consuming, and to expose the film fully, the room had to be kept at high temperatures and brightly-lit with carbon arc lighting. These strict conditions resulted in overheating and eye strain for actors, an issue pertinent to the Lion in The Wizard Of Oz. Bert Lahr’s costume was made from an actual lion hide that weighed in at around 90lbs, allowing little to no ventilation. Together with the extreme temperatures demanded by colour technology, Lahr endured a challenging on-set experience. Constantly sweating during filming, his costume had to be dried at the end of each day because it was so drenched with sweat. Such issues were not restricted to Lahr either; with Jack Haley’s Tin Man suit made of actual metal, his costume absorbed heat rapidly. Thus, while colour technology livened the cinematic experience for us spectators, creating the ‘golden’ age that we all fondly recall and reminisce about, the practical realities of filming in colour conditioned an adverse filming experience for actors.   

The practical realities of filming in colour conditioned an adverse filming experience for actors

Talking pictures – engaging or exclusive? 

The displacement of silent films by talking pictures gained momentum during the late 1920s and was most famously popularised by the 1927 musical drama The Jazz Singer, which was one of the first feature-length motion pictures to incorporate synchronised dialogue and singing. This privileging of sound enabled greater psychological investment for viewers, who were no longer required to read subtitles or rely solely on silent gestures and titles. With such limited need for conscious analysis, attending the cinema operated as a form of leisure, underpinning the notion of old Hollywood as one of the ‘golden’ times. Yet as the possibilities of an audible experience expanded, so did the gap between major production companies and independent competitors. While major studio systems invested in expensive microphones, high-quality sound-mixing equipment and vast in-house orchestras, thousands of smaller businesses could not replicate such purchases. As such, the rise of sound catalysed the erasure of independent businesses facing corporate monopolisation. This hierarchy continued until the 1948 Supreme Court ruling, which recognised the domination of big production companies and motioned the rise of greater creative competition. Thus, while sound aided an emotionally immersive experience for spectators, producing a kind of ‘golden’ revolution, the advances bore negative effects for independents, pushing them out of the picture – no pun intended – as Paramount and Warner Bros assumed total influence.   

Moreover, the introduction of sound led to discrimination against minority actors, as companies sought to appeal to mainstream white audiences. For example, the Japanese-born actor Sessue Hayakawa, one of the only actors to command a salary that rivalled Charlie Chaplin, experienced slander against his Japanese accent, with The New York Times stressing how “his lines are not always spoken so that one can understand them”. Production companies eventually used this as justification for his relegation.

So, was old Hollywood as ‘golden’ as we might think, and should we continue to view these films as such given the controversies that were so central to their functioning? In terms of audience experience alone, the welcoming of technicolour and sound brought a new degree of psychological immersion that was indeed somewhat ‘golden’. Yet to view solely from this angle is to discard the experiences of all those involved – from cast members to independent competitors. Once we examine the unfavourable realities of the latter, it becomes evident that old Hollywood was not truly ‘golden’ for all.  

Image: Annie Spratt via Unsplash