The FIFA poppy concession was no victory

By Patrick Fletcher

As last Saturday’s England’s football friendly with Spain drew near, sandwiched between the 11th November and Remembrance Sunday, the FA’s plans for the team to wear poppy-embroidered shirts was stifled by FIFA. Cue national outrage and nauseating anglocentrism.

As EDL members protested from the roof of FIFA’s HQ in Zurich and the outraged David Cameron found time to pen a letter of complaint, the true significance of the symbol of the poppy was threatened to be lost among the hot-headed indignation. When FIFA announced last Wednesday that England’s black armbands would be allowed to feature a picture of a poppy, knee-jerk reactions of ‘victory’ and ‘justice’ were voiced and the point was missed.

’How dare they?!’ was the general sentiment. The corrupt FIFA and the English-hating Sepp Blatter having it in for the English yet again! The outcry smacked of petulance – hardly surprising given that expectancy and entitlement are common symptoms of English football of recent years. England was outraged, and it couldn’t understand why an exception wasn’t being made for it. This anglocentrism became jingoistic, Harry Redknapp writing that, “If we do not stand up to this ridiculous kind of meddling — this interfering in our traditions — then I see a time in 20, 30 or 40 years’ time when Remembrance Sunday itself will be banned”.

During this period of hot-headed indignation, a cloud was cast over the whole affair, making people lose sight of the very reason why we wanted to wear the poppy in the first place. It was turned into an embittered conflict with world football’s governing body, used by some to stoke the flames of the anti-FIFA agenda popularised by our failed World Cup bid.

The wearing of the poppy was in danger of becoming a case of just winning a battle. Such a distraction threatened to undermine the purity of our act of remembrance, which seemed sad and absurd since the absence of a poppy on a shirt shouldn’t render remembrance impossible. Indeed for 93 years England have honoured the war dead during its football matches without a poppy on the shirt.

FIFA didn’t construct a barrier to remembrance – in seeing this as a national affront and in identifying an enemy, we did. Ironically, an infinitely stronger and more relevant act of defiance would have been to lay the outrage and bitterness to one side and to concentrate on not letting such controversy cloud our original intentions.

But even when handed a lifeline, some pressed on with the same futile discourse. On the Wednesday before the game, FIFA and the FA reached a compromise and it was decided that England’s black armbands would be allowed to be embroidered with the poppy. This was an important opportunity, one that we didn’t really deserve and one that was somewhat spurned.

Across the twittersphere and red-top press, cries of ‘victory!’ rang out. We, the mighty English had triumphed in adversity. When FIFA stood in our way, we forced them to back down – justice had been done. England had spat its dummy out and like a spoiled brat had got its own way, but the point went flying over its head in the process.

Victory? It was nothing of the sort. The battle was of our own making, and when we were offered a way out, our fierce pride stood in our way. This futile triumphalism threatened to undermine the sobriety and essence of the occasion. On some level, the armband was worn with two fingers raised defiantly in FIFA’s direction. The dignified thing to do would have been to play down any controversy, not to play up to it.

Over the weekend and last couple of weeks, the lives and deaths of brave soldiers have been remembered in poignant and dignified ways. The FA and England football team made their contribution, but with an unnecessary and acerbic sub-plot.