The fallout from Alaa Abd El-Fattah’s return to the UK

By Amelia Greenwood

The recent return of British citizen Alaa Abd el-Fattah to the UK after having spent the last 12 years imprisoned in Egypt was initially praised for its immense diplomatic success, but has since been soured by resurfaced tweets made by Abd el-Fattah which have raised questions about the due diligence of the Foreign Office and even calls for the revocation of his citizenship.

Abd el-Fattah, a prominent pro-democracy and human rights activist, rose to international prominence in 2011 for his key role in the Tahrir Square protest which brought about the overthrowing of Egypt’s dictatorial president Hosni Mubarak. However, this success for the Arab Spring movement of pro-democracy and anti-corruption was undermined by the military takeover that replaced Mubarak, taking control through violent means with successive destructive clashes culminating in the 2013 Rabaa massacre. This military repression saw Abd el-Fattah arrested and imprisoned, experiencing inhumane treatment as well as torture and being subject to a travel ban following his eventual release, which hindered his return to the UK. This release was hard fought by fellow human rights activists and Abd el-Fattah’s family, with his mother Laila Soueif admitted to hospital twice whilst on a hunger strike. The success of this fight for freedom was understandably considered a huge diplomatic achievement, so how and why has this soured?

”Abd El-Fattah … rose to international prominence in 2011 for his key role in the Tahrir Square protest”

It was rediscovered following Abd el-Fattah’s return to the UK on the 26th of December that he had made hateful and provocative tweets primarily regarding his frustrations with Zionism and with Egyptian police brutality. These tweets have since been widely condemned across the political spectrum and by Abd el-Fattah himself on the platform #FreeAlaa which was originally used to campaign for his release, recognising them as “expressions of a young man’s anger” that he regrets and apologises for. These tweets have been broadly recognised for their wrongness but there is no consensus on how they should be handled. Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has taken the opportunity to call for the revocation of his citizenship and deportation back to Egypt, disregarding the protections of citizenship law and turning to sympathetic media outlets like GB News to call upon his loyal followers and utilise anti-immigration sentiment.

Abd el-Fattah’s British citizenship was granted by Boris Johnson’s government in 2021 due to his mother’s birth in the UK. British citizenship has strong legal protection so once granted is rarely revoked, making it unlikely that Farage’s call will be answered. The decade-old tweets of an otherwise peaceful, pro-democracy human rights activists, who has spent the last 12 years isolated from his family in inhumane conditions, are not broadly considered to warrant a response of the degree that right-wing proponents are suggesting. It is clear that the nature of Abd el-Fattah’s tweets requires closer inspection but retroactive punishment through deportation does not appear to be the most logical or safe course of action. Deportation to Egypt would likely be dangerous for Abd el-Fattah and would create immense diplomatic tensions through the disregard of a complex battle for freedom that has seen the efforts of four Prime Ministers and multiple international human rights agencies.

”The more pressing concern is one of bureaucratic inadequacies and the lack of due diligence that has become clear in the government’s unawareness of the tweets prior to Abd el-Fattah’s release”

The more pressing concern is one of bureaucratic inadequacies and the lack of due diligence that has become clear in the government’s unawareness of the tweets prior to Abd el-Fattah’s release. There is no doubt that such publicly accessible information should have been known to the Foreign Office, especially since they were widely enough known and condemned in 2014 to cost him the Sakharov Prize for Freedom of Thought, showing a glaring error in procedural aspects of government. The money and resources expended to control citizenship does not appear to ensure thorough research before decisions are made regarding the fate of individuals who seek protection through citizenship. Foreign Secretary Yvette Cooper has opened an investigation into this error, reviewing the procedural systems that allowed this oversight.

It remains to be seen how these recent developments will impact Alaa Abd el-Fattah’s life in the UK and more alarmingly how the government will respond to such clear institutional incompetence.

Image: Gigi Ibrahim via Wikimedia Commons