The fallacy of Tory “Big Society” Plans
In the build-up to the General Election last May, David Cameron unveiled his concept of the ‘Big Society’ as the central vision for British social policy under a Conservative government. If we accept Cameron’s sincerity, this is a remarkable volta-face in recent Conservative policy, as Thatcher proclaimed that ‘there is no such thing as society’; when British society was finally recognised, it was ‘broken’. Only in the last year, when pressed with an election, have the Conservatives finally offered an optimistic vision for British society.
Although in principle these developments could be commended as a return to a more compassionate form of ‘One Nation Toryism’, Cameron’s ‘Big Society’ has been subject to high levels of cynicism. Perhaps this is unfair, merely the outgrowth of prejudice against the upper-class background of Cameron and the Conservatives more generally. After all, it is worth remembering that Cameron and his comrades in the Bullingdon Club were hugely active in the redecoration of many of Oxford’s restaurants and bars, to the pleasant surprise of the management.
Nevertheless, the disinterest that the ‘Big Society’ evokes is not primarily due to the unlikeliness of seeing Osborne et al. pick litter on their Sunday afternoons. Indeed, much of its potential success rests on a direct appeal to the wealthy to participate more in local community projects, as the ‘Big Society’ plans to ‘take power away from politicians and give it to people’, whereby Britain would wean itself from the overwhelming embrace of the state and restore community support along the basis of voluntary participatory organization.
The problem is the rhetoric does not meet with the reality. The ‘Big Society’ is merely a half-hearted post-script to the government’s austerity measures to enshrine the principle of ‘small’ government at the core of Thatcherite Conservatism as the new consensus in British politics. This ideology is crucially pre-occupied with a perceived glut of state bureaucracy rather than community relations and regularly employs mock moral outrage to justify its claims. Witness, for example, Eric Pickles’ on-going assault on those public sector employees who earn over £100,000 per annum whose obscene salaries detract from frontline services; a worthy cause, were it not for that fact that less than 1% of local government employees earn over £60,000. These arguments are particularly acute regarding the NHS, where the Conservatives are strongly aware that frontline cuts are unpopular and so masquerade as an assault on management.
As with all great myths, there is an element of truth to the accusations levelled against public-sector bureaucracy. Yet according to a recent study by the House of Commons library the cuts have, almost without exception, fallen upon poorer Labour councils while wealthy Tory councils, such as Gove’s Surrey, have hardly been affected. Even more crucially, the flaw in the ‘Big Society’ is that its moralizing about inequalities of wealth is limited to civil servants, rather than wider British society. We are supposed to suspend belief and contend that the ‘fat cats’ that caused the recession were mid-to-high level bureaucrats, while the salaries of high-earning bankers are once again untouchable and justifiable.
The core ideal of the ‘Big Society’ is, therefore, an attempt to rehabilitate the vast social inequalities of wealth produced by neoliberal economics within a fully enfranchised state. By introducing the ‘Big Society’ alongside ‘permanent austerity’, Cameron is attempting to remove the principle of state welfare and replace it with a revitalised form of philanthropic voluntarism, underpinned by the modern obsession with entrepreneurialism. The alternative, localized communitarianism, is what Ed Miliband envisages when he speaks of ‘reclaiming’ the ‘Big Society’, yet it has merely been paid lip-service to; although Cameron would undoubtedly not oppose this development, his recent suggestions that local people run post-offices, along with other public services, simply fails to recognise how busy modern Britons are. After all, if Nat Wei, the ‘big society tsar’ can only volunteer two days a week to work on its projects due to the need to spend time with his family and earn income, how will ordinary people manage?
The outcome will not be the ‘Big Society’ but rather the ‘Secret Millionaire Society’, where the fawning masses will graciously receive whatever scraps our economic supermen deign to cast us. Recent comments by senior Conservatives have alluded to this. Francis Maude has spoken of the need to foster a ‘more visible’ form of competitive philanthropy on the American model, which Boris Johnson has echoed, calling for philanthropists to be ‘publicly identified as being generous and a big person on the stage of giving’. Indeed, while Johnson recognised that current levels of inequality were approaching Victorian levels, his only gripe was that this hadn’t been matched by a Victorian sense of giving.
This exposes the wholesale lack of novelty within Cameron’s vision. Voluntarism is a principle that has been at the heart of modern British politics, forming the core of nineteenth- and early-twentieth century Parliamentary attitudes towards social legislation before being discarded because it proved wholly incapable to provide adequate security for a mass electorate. Voluntarism as the basis of social is unsustainable precisely because it is emerges from what the donor perceives is most important, often influenced by slick advertising and celebrity endorsements. In practice, this would place lifeboats, animals, cancer and overseas disasters at the summit of pressing social ills. Moreover, it is precisely in times of recession that donations are withdrawn, as people follow precisely the same logic of ‘belt-tightening’ as the government, as shown by the failure of Hoover to deal with the emerging Great Depression. The popular sentiment of those who lived through the last major downturn under ‘small’ government is unmistakeable. To those that think charity can provide adequate housing, try out a Hooverville. To those who feel that charity can adequately take up the slack of the NHS, try watching An Inspector Calls or The Citadel. And to those that believe philanthropy is a strong indicator of quality of life for the poor, ask where they would rather live: America or Sweden.
Underneath the contemporary fetish for entrepreneurism and devolution of power as the cure for all social ills, the ‘Big Society’ thus fundamentally represents an attempt to justify to the public with the huge levels of inequality inevitably generated by neoliberalism. The result will be a postcode lottery of welfare provisions based on the whims of the wealthy rather than the needs of the poor, where those in need can no longer look to the State to aid them and must turn to Johnson’s local ‘big man’, Godfather-style, for help. The perversity of Tory logic is obvious. We must not allow the Conservatives to use the moral argument against inequality to solidify a more unequal state, and we must not allow the recent failings of the capitalist system to facilitate a ‘popular’ assault on social welfare. Otherwise, our ‘Big Society’ will be populated by little people more distant from their ‘big man’ beneficiaries than ever

