The elderly: disrespected and forgotten
In Japan there is an emerging demographic crisis. One in four of the population will be above 65 years of age come 2014, according to data compiled by the US Census Bureau. By 2030, it will be one in three. It “costs several tens of millions of yen” a month to treat a single patient in the final stages of life, says Taro Aso, finance minister and deputy prime minister. “The problem won’t be solved unless you let them hurry up and die.”
Time magazine ran an article in 2010Â about the increasingly common phenomenon of kodokushi, or “lonely deaths”, in Japan, describing how “the people die alone, sprawled on the floor beside crumpled clothing and dirty dishes, tucked beneath flowery bedspreads, slouched against the wall.” The article explained that many of the elderly increasingly live alone, without or neglected by family, and die alone.
We can see this type of attitude reflected in Aso’s speech, where he calls those dependent on continuous medical care “tube people.” Tube people… This dehumanizing designation is perhaps symptomatic of a larger problem: a loss of respect for the elderly, in a culture famous for respect.
In a way, this parallels the situation here in the UK. In February 2012, The Guardian reported on the “crisis on social care” for older people, especially women, due to decreasing funding, so much so that the quality of care (such as it is) at times breaches human rights. A woman named Mary is quoted, saying, “I’ve got no one left to help and support me. I’m lonely and I’m isolated. And I’m scared about the future.” The Care Quality Commission 2012 even reported on a lack of dignity and respect given to elderly patients in one in ten NHS hospitals inspected, regarding “a care culture in which the unacceptable becomes the norm”.
The reason is probably simple. In Japan, Aso’s attitude is summed up in this exclamation: “Why should I have to pay for people who just eat and drink and make no effort? I walk every day and do other things, but I’m paying more in taxes.” As admirable as that kind of work ethic is, is it everyone’s responsibility continue to work until death? Or maybe everyone should die after they retire? Is that really what Aso belives?
In George Herbert’s 1633 poem “The Pulley”, the speaker takes on the voice of God and explains that while a person might become rich in this life, they shall never attain rest until they finally go to God to seek reprieve from their “weariness”. This exemplifies the ultimate goal of a human being: to rest after life’s vicissitudes and struggles. That is to say, retired people are former working people; when a person has worked for decades, is it not appropriate to attain some form of rest?
Even removing any form of employment, health care, such as it is available, is a fundamental human right. Is not the entire concept of progressive taxation in order to redistribute income so that those who have less are helped by those who have more?
Aso tried to save himself by insisting that he was merely stating his “personal belief”, not the direction he believes the medical care system should take. Yet, as a leader of a country, one’s responsibility is the country, its people and its systems. The leaders’ opinions are precisely the direction they believe the system should take. Aso’s callous dismissal of the matter therefore speaks to me of a kind of irresponsibility that does not bode well for the future of Japan’s elderly.
Many in the UK today are calling for reform of the welfare system. Perhaps it would do to remember the dedication of those thousands of care workers who do a fantastic job, and that we should not tar all care homes with the same brush. Nonetheless, reform is likely what is needed in the UK, and I can easily say the same for Japan – not only reform of the welfare system, but of the system that has seen seven changes of prime minister in six years, marked by a string of resignations; a system that has brought Aso to the position of Finance Minister and deputy Prime Minister.
To his credit, Aso does emphasis the element of choice in saying, “Heaven forbid if you are forced to live on when you want to die.” I only wish that this statement were not so blind to the many people who really do not want to die… That this statement were not so blatant an imposition of his “personal belief” on others. Freedom of choice and the independent self of the people of his country are ideas Taro Aso would do well to take to heart, especially in matters of life and death.

