The economic consequences of Nigel Farage
The verdict, it would seem, is in. Like it or not, Europe has voted for increased segregation in the European Union.
In Britain, Nigel Farage’s euro-sceptic UK Independence Party (UKIP) managed to transform the hype into tangible results: a victory that almost doubled their number of Member of European Parliament (MEPs).
In France, Marine Le Pen’s Front National polled first and in Greece, the neo-Nazi Golden Dawn gained MEPs for the first time.
Austria designated four seats to the Freedom Party, a term not so accurate when it comes to their position on immigrants.
Alternative for Germany, the European powerhouse’s Eurosceptic party, also made gains.
Collectively the European Parliament still consists of a majority of pro-EU faithful, but many of the individual members of these parties are Euro-sceptics themselves.
In short, Europe is becoming more divided.
However, what does this mean for the British economy?
Mr.Farage wants to convince us that our, ‘£55m a day’ spending on the EU is a waste of taxpayer money. His ‘current-account’ view of Britain, which focuses only on money in minus money out, fails to recognize the very worrying future for the continent if further division occurs.
Admittedly, many of the problems arising from a more divided Europe are specifically applicable to Euro-zone member states (EU countries who share the same currency). This still impacts the UK as most of the UK’s trade comes from within the EU, and most of the EU lies within the Eurozone.
Currencies are useful in dealing with poor demand for a country’s products. A quick devaluation makes products cheaper to foreign consumers so they increase demand and the economy picks up again.
With a shared currency, here lies the problem.
One country cannot use the Euro to cater to its own personal needs when the other countries may want different things. For example, there may be one country that might not want devaluation as it would push up the price of imports and thus could cause inflation. In effect when sharing a currency, your ability to manipulate your currency ends.
When a country loses the ability to change its exchange rate, it must find other ways of helping its economy.
One such way is allowing prices to fall. This, like devaluation, would make goods cheaper for foreign consumers and thus will allow demand to pick back up.
Without free migration, this has to come from workers voluntarily reducing wages and firms reducing prices.
Unfortunately, for a variety of reasons, wages and prices are sticky meaning a recession persists until wages can adjust through unemployment and prices adjust through businesses going bust. More people on social assistance means people will be willing to work for less and more businesses failing means that firms have to reduce prices in order to survive.
However, it is not all glum. A Europe with free migration can increase efficiency.
Say we have two countries, one in a recession and one experiencing inflation that is causing boom.
Wages will obviously be higher in the boom country than in the recession one, and workers in the recession country will therefore be attracted by the higher wages to relocate to the boom country.
This reduces the labour supply in the recession country and increases it in the boom country, as workers move from one country to the other.
A higher labour supply means wages start to fall as the workers are more abundant and thus cannot demand as high wages.
A lower labour supply means wages start to increase. Labour will keep on moving from recession country to boom country until the wages have moved enough for them to be equal, and thus there is no more incentive for labour migration.
The effect is reducing unemployment in a negatively affected country without using exchange rates.
Now here is where UKIP come in. The new batch of Eurosceptic MEPs are not particularly fond of immigration, and whilst they may not be able to restrict free movement completely, they could certainly try and make it more difficult.
This effect makes it more likely that countries stay in recession. In addition, Eurozone countries in recession can lead to Britain in recession due to interdependency of trade.
Another way of helping out hurting economies could come from a centrally planned reallocation of resources.
Say Greece is in trouble it cannot use its exchange rate, but an injection of cash from the EU could help. This injection could either be explicit, where you simply just hand money over to the government, or implicit through benefits.
The more Greeks out of work means more benefits paid out. This is all funded by the countries that are doing well (normally Germany), and might even help towards that country combat inflation. This whole system of payments does not look likely to sit too well with Mr.Farage and the Euro-skeptic faithful.
Increased European segregation could lead to non-tariff barriers and potentially conservative amendments to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU). Whilst currently the law under Article 34 TFEU prevents Member States from placing quantitative restrictions or using other strategies that have equivalent effect, this could change if a collective segregationist movement in Europe gains momentum. The effect of non-tariff barriers would be decreased trade making it more arduous for Britain firms to export.
Perhaps the most pressing danger of Mr.Farage’s philosophy is that people will find it difficult to work with other EU countries. It could result in the end of the EU dream of free movement of workers providing services in a range of different countries, firms being able to source out cheaper suppliers from a much larger selection pool, partnerships increasing between firms, best practices being shared and ideas spreading faster.
Nigel Farage’s proposals for separate trade agreements with different member countries fail to bring out,to their full potential, these networking effects.
Surely, we are better off working within Europe to try and increase ties with the rest of the world? We stand a far better chance than going it alone.
Photograph: geralt

