The Dictators’ Democracy
by Harriette Douglas
At a recent debate the Durham Union Society asked whether the West – by which is meant Western Europe and the USA – has a duty to impose democracy. The phrase ‘to impose democracy’ is problematic, because it suggests that it is inflicted or forced upon people by Western authorities rather than adopted by them as the preferred means of self-government.
This appears to be where people get confused. The issue at hand is not whether democracy is a good system, or whether the West should intervene to help victims of genocide and war crimes and protect those whose human rights are being blatantly violated, to which the answer is generally ‘yes’, but whether having entered a country, it is appropriate to impose our own system of government.
The answer, to that question, simply, is ‘no’. The idea of imposing democracy is oxymoronic. Certainly, in the furtherance of its human rights agenda the West has a duty to support democracy when it begins to bloom in other countries, and a responsibility to help to protect those in need, but to impose our system of governance is both aggressive and arrogant. Democracy cannot be imposed at the barrel of a gun; it must be allowed to grow naturally as an expression of the free will of the people who live under it. Otherwise how are the interveners any better than the despots they claim need to be removed?
The second, and very complicated question, is when and with what reason the West should intervene in the affairs of another country, especially when the initial intervention is uninvited. The fact that it can be done does not mean it should be done in all cases. It is important to realise that the West rarely enters a country under the pretext of imposing democracy. In fact, it rarely enters the countries that are most in need.
Take the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, as examples which are specific to the USA and Britain, and not the West as a whole. The justification for intervening in these countries was national security – ours, not theirs. This is a wholly self-interested motive, but it is one which, tragically, is often used by the West as a reason for intervention, and this is evident if one considers the countries such countries have chosen to enter in recent history.
No weapons of ‘mass destruction’ were actually found in Iraq following its invasion by the US and other NATO forces, and there are many who believe that the real reason that the West entered Iraq was in fact to access the country’s wealth of natural resources. This does not appear entirely implausible when you look at the lack of Western intervention in Africa, where in some countries there are daily human rights violations.
Conversely, the West barely made any attempt to go to the aid of the Rwandan people when they were being butchered in vast numbers. It is estimated that over eight hundred thousand people died in the 1994 Rwandan genocide. What did the West do to help? They sent in a small UN team with a mandate to only act in their own self-defence, to shoot if they were shot at, but not to prevent those using machetes to hack their neighbours in half. Ignorance is not an excuse for their lack of action. The situation was certainly grave enough for them to remove all Western citizens. Did they deem their lives more valuable than those of close to a million Rwandans? The failure of the West to intervene in these circumstances was scandalous.
Since then an apology has been issued to the Rwandan people with the promise “never again”. However, if one looks at the situation in Zimbabwe at the moment, the presence of corruption and serious criminal activity can hardly be denied. Channel 4 produced a compelling documentary entitled ‘Mugabe and the White African’, which details Mugabe’s attack on white farmers who he wants to chase off their land. Where does the West stand in this case?
As Zimbabwe provides most of Africa’s home produce it is more obvious why other African nations hesitate to intervene. The West condemns this but is not quick to intervene itself. Why? Perhaps the logical conclusion is that there is no personal or political advantage for them to do so, and it must be remembered that they initially supported Mugabe’s rise to power.
Much of the problem rests with the UN’s inability to agree on the course of action necessary to deal with these problems. Unfortunately it is heavily reliant on the West, particularly the USA, for financial and military support, hence America’s influence on UN policy. Some kind of reform is needed here so that it is not the victims of war torn countries that suffer as a result. In short, the UN has in the past and is failing now to suppress acts of genocide and prevent the violation of human rights across the globe, or render real help to the victims of such crimes.
Still, we need to return to the question at hand. To say that the West has no right, let alone duty, to impose democracy on others is not to say that governments should sit on their hands. The West absolutely should not stand by and do nothing while atrocities are committed, but equally when it is decided that intervention is necessary the reasons need to be carefully laid out and considered. Is action in the interest of the West or the victims? In order to help those who are suffering the West’s motives must be pure.
However, to help is not to impose anything. The West has a responsibility to encourage and support democracy where it begins to flourish, but to use force and authority in a nation not your own is to provoke a hostile reaction that can only cause negative long-term relations. The duty is to help those countries that want to develop a system of democratic government, and this can be done in many ways short of armed intervention, and all peaceful means should be exhausted before force is resorted to.

