The demise of compassionate conservatism

By Jack KellamDavidCameron


Last week’s revelations that the Conservative Party have attempted to clear the internet of all their speeches and press releases pre-dating the last general election finally makes obvious what has long been suspected: “Call Me Dave”, compassionate conservatism is dead in the water.

This concerted effort to cut ties with the ‘detoxified’ brand image clarifies the tactics the Tories will be making use of from now until 2015.

‘Cameronite’ centrist, green, socially-caring conservatism will give way to the same old ‘nasty party’ that believes the public sector to be ‘wasteful’, scaremongers about immigrants and the EU, and demonises anyone who claims benefits.

A brief browse through the sorts of statements, speeches, and press releases removed from the Internet; and then the subsequent policies that the coalition government have pursued underlines this.

Firstly, prior to May 2010, various senior Tory figures including the future Health Secretary Andrew Lansley and current Prime Minister promised an end to “top-down re-structures… of the NHS,” a ring-fencing of the organisation’s budget, and no frontline cuts.

However, the NHS in England is currently undergoing arguably the biggest top-down reorganisation in its history, experiencing real-term cuts to its budget, and has lost 5,870 nurses and 7,968 hospital beds since the last general election.

In August 2009, George Osborne admitted that bankers’ bonuses “must stop” as they are “totally unacceptable.” In the last month, he has been taking legal action against the European Commission’s plan to cap such bonuses at 200% of a salary.

On numerous occasions before his party entered office, Cameron pledged to make his “the greenest government ever.” He insisted that “green taxes as a whole need to go up,” and at the launch of the 2008 local election campaign declared “vote blue, go green.” Current Conservative policy, however, is to “roll back” the green taxes on fuel bills.

Perhaps most pertinent, though, is the promise Cameron made not long after May 2010 that his party “didn’t come into politics to make cuts.”

Austerity was needed to balance the books, nothing more. Although many knew that this was never seriously the case, at the Lord Mayor’s Ball last week – in front of an audience of City of London chief executives and multimillionaires – he admitted that his party’s vision was for “a leaner, more efficient state.” More must be done with less, “not just now, but permanently.” Austerity is here to stay.

Why such a change in tack?

For starters, the right-wing-populist policies of the United Kingdom Independence Party (UKIP) present a growing electoral threat to the Tories.

UKIP are regularly polling 12% of the vote, and are widely predicted to win next year’s European elections.

Previously solid Conservative voters who have never really identified themselves with the party of same-sex marriage, are increasingly drawn across by the traditional jingoism of Farage et al. As the Tories likely need to increase their share of the vote in 2015 to govern alone, they cannot afford to bleed any more votes to UKIP.

This is not to mention the influence of increasingly disgruntled Tory backbenchers – a group composed largely of radical free-marketers, staunch Eurosceptics, and climate change deniers. Respectively convinced that the UK’s economic woes can be blamed on sluggish austerity measures, the European Union, or environmentalism, they are similarly certain that UKIP’s rise is simply because their party is “not right-wing enough.” Worried about losing what they see as “their party” as well as their seats, mounting pressure has been put on Cameron to move right towards a more “traditional” Toryism.

However, the strongest reason for the death of Cameron’s brand of “compassionate” conservatism is that, to a decent extent, their retreat to the cynical politics of “divide and rule” is being proven effective. Setting public sector against private sector, UK nationals against immigrants, and “strivers” against “scroungers” gives people someone concrete to blame in times of economic hardship. The challenge for those of us on the left is to react positively against this. Now that Cameron has ceased to be an optimist about Britain, it left to us to offer a degree of hope.

Photograph:  UK Department for International Development