The Debate: The Presidential Electoral System
Last year’s re-election of Barack Obama has re-opened the debate in America over its presidential electoral system, primarily over the future of the controversial Electoral College and its role in influencing the selection of the next leader of the free world.
The College, the final stage in the presidential election process, has the potential to distort the votes of the American public to such an extent that a majority in the public vote might not simply guarantee a candidate his seat in The Oval Office. As part of the 1787 Constitution, the College was of course the result of compromise. In this case the matter was settled between those who believed a purely public vote could be too reckless and those who objected to giving Congress the sole power to select the president.
To this day, the original process remains largely unchanged. Each state has a number of votes equal to the number of its Senators, two in each state, plus the number of its House Representatives, which varies according to population. Including three votes for Washington DC, a successful candidate requires a majority of 270 from a final total of 538. In this allocation lies the first problem of the system: small states such as Wyoming are disproportionately overrepresented in the Electoral College. Each person’s vote in these smaller states is comparatively “worth more” due to the misallocation of votes per state. To put it into figures; in 2004, California had one Electoral College vote for every 617,000 constituents. If California was granted one vote for every 167,000, as Wyoming were, they would have had 205 votes instead of only 55.
However, the real downfall of the process is how the overall public vote can be unnecessarily distorted by the winner-takes-all system employed in 48 of America’s 50 states. As the name suggests, the winning candidate in the particular state takes all of its Electoral College votes, no matter how close the contest. This means, in the grander scheme of things, the final Electoral College results can be significantly misrepresentative of the general vote. In 1996, Clinton won only 49% of the popular vote but over 70% in the Electoral College. More recently, the 2012 election appeared to be a close race until the Electoral College mechanism was factored in. Overall, Obama did pip Romney to the simple public vote with 51% to the Republican’s 47%. The results were dramatically different in the College. Obama won over 62% of the votes while Romney took a mere 32%, giving the impression of an overwhelming victory. Nothing summed up the inadequacy of current system more than the presidential election of 2000. In one of the closest White House elections of all time, the final result came down to the 25 votes of the state of Florida. Despite Al Gore winning 48.4% of the country’s approval, Bush clinched the presidency with only 48% by marginally winning the local contest in Florida and thus taking all of their College votes. What is more, this outdated system also disadvantages third parties on the national stage, as the unfortunate Ross Perot will testify, and discourages voter turnout in states underrepresented in the College whose individual voters feel their votes are of little worth.
While the Electoral College may have been a practical solution in the dawn of America’s nationhood, in the twenty-first century the Founding Fathers’ creation appears to be outmoded and unnecessary. For a country that prides itself so much on its claims to a model-for-all democracy, the continued inadequacy and palpable unfairness of the Electoral College seems hard to comprehend. A simple plurality system, a straight nationwide vote, would provide the most sensible and obvious solution to a situation that should have been rectified years ago. Though the Electoral College may not have dramatically affected the result of last year’s election, it is scary to think that this obsolete feature might have the potential to elect the most powerful man on Earth, against the majority of his country’s wishes.
Photograph: Flickr ID – publik18

