The debate over overhauling the UK asylum system has intensified
By Calum Steer
More than 800 migrants crossed the English Channel to the UK on August 21st, setting a new record for crossings in a single day. In response, the government has authorised Border Force officials to turn back UK-bound migrant boats under specific circumstances. While the government states that the tactic would be “safe and legal”, charities argue that it would break international refugee laws, and that it is inhumane.
Is this a picture of what is to come as the government hopes to implement its New Plan for Immigration through the Nationality and Borders Bill? It has now been backed by MPs in its second reading in the House of Commons. Home Secretary Priti Patel has set out what she calls a “firm and fair” overhaul to the way people applying for asylum are treated. For the first time, people seeking protection as refugees would have their claim assessed based on how they arrive in the UK.
The New Plan could see Border Force officials gaining greater powers to turn away UK-bound migrant boats
Refugees arriving via “illegal routes”, by crossing the Channel on small boats, for example, would only receive temporary permission to remain and would be regularly assessed for removal from the UK. The Refugee Council’s Enver Solomon said this would artificially and unjustly differentiate “between the deserving and undeserving refugee”. The government, however, defends the plan based on its supposed fairness, legality, and the safety it would allegedly provide for migrants and UK nationals. It is these three central issues that have been spotlighted in the furious asylum debate.
Priti Patel has pledged to fix the “fundamentally broken” asylum system and to introduce a “faster and fairer” one that “better supports the most vulnerable”. She says that the current system advances “those with the means to pay smugglers over those in desperate need” and is currently “clogged up” with legal wrangles and bogus claims. The government would seek the “rapid removal” of rejected applicants. But asylum seekers coming to the UK via legal routes, such as its official resettlement schemes, would immediately gain permission to remain indefinitely.
What Ms Patel has called “asylum shopping” will be deterred under the New Plan. The Home Secretary states that “if you illegally enter the UK via a safe country in which you could have claimed asylum, you are not seeking refuge from imminent peril, as is the intended purpose of the asylum system, but are picking the UK as a preferred destination over others.” The New Plan could, therefore, see Border Force officials gaining greater powers to turn away UK-bound migrant boats.
The government has received heavy backlash for the proposals
Ms Patel states that efforts to travel to the UK on small boats will be further deterred by cracking down on people smugglers, who often facilitate dangerous channel crossings. “Enough is enough”: the government aims to introduce life sentences for people smugglers. Such a policy is claimed to be in the interest of safety, both for migrants and UK nationals. Ms Patel has said that “families and young children have lost their lives at sea, in lorries and in shipping having put their trust in the hands of criminals.” The Home Secretary argues that it is these same criminal gangs who are involved in “serious violent crimes” in the UK such as trafficking guns and drugs.
However, the government has received heavy backlash for the proposals. First, refugee charities have questioned the claimed ‘fairness’ of the system, emphasising the importance of understanding how we define ‘entering illegally’. Director of the Migration Observatory at Oxford University, Madeleine Sumpton, said it was “slightly misleading to say people have a choice between the legal and illegal route”. “Asylum seekers often struggle to obtain identity documents from the state they’re being persecuted by and can’t travel legitimately without such documents”, says Helen O’Nien, founder of the Center for Rights and Justice at Nottingham Trent University. The Joint Council for The Welfare of Immigrants argues that the proposals would create a two-tiered asylum system based on invented distinctions between ‘good’ and ‘bad’ migrants.
“Asylum seekers often struggle to obtain identity documents from the state they’re being persecuted by and can’t travel legitimately without such documents”
Many have also criticised the government’s assertion that the plans would be in the interests of migrant safety. Labour has said the New Plan would do “next to nothing to stop people making dangerous crossings” or deal with criminal gangs. Steve Valdez-Symonds, Amnesty International UK’s Refugee and Migrant Rights Director, said asylum seekers “only make dangerous journeys and rely on smugglers because there are no safe alternatives made available to them”. Under current legislation, migrants must reach the UK before making an asylum claim and there is no way of asking for permission to enter the UK in order to claim asylum. Although the New Plan states the objective of “broadening the scope of the UK’s protection offer” through resettlement schemes, the Refugee Council is concerned that “the proposals do nothing to achieve this.”
Questions remain as to whether the government’s plans are even lawful or deliverable. Under the UK’s Human Rights Act 1998, the state is obliged to prevent people from being returned to places of inhuman and degrading treatment or cruel and unusual punishment. Furthermore, the Refugee Convention prohibits turning away refugees who have entered illegally, as long as they can show they’ve come directly from a place of persecution and a reasonable cause for their actions. Even if migrants have entered the UK through a ‘safe third country’ such as France, the UK has no formalised method for returning migrants to those countries. After Brexit, the Dublin Regulation, which enabled the UK to return some asylum seekers to EU member states without considering their asylum claims, no longer applies.
The ethical, legal and bureaucratic storm surrounding the refugee issue continues to rage and is not forecast to subside any time soon.
Image: adamansel52 via Flickr

