The Death of the Cult Film

By Alexander Cohen

The paradigm shift in cinema marked by the emergence of Netflix and Amazon Prime has radically changed the way we engage in films. Dwindling cinema numbers and binge watching are part and parcel of this new age of streaming. This new paradigm has also influenced the content we consume, not just the way we consume it: “made for Netflix shows” or “Amazon prime exclusives” are a ubiquitous feature of our entertainment experiences. With this new dawn, some aspects of the former paradigm will be relinquished to the past. One of those aspects is the cult film. 

The essence of the cult film is nebulous. What does it mean for a film to be a cult film? Some cult films fall under the “so bad its good” category. This includes offerings like Sharknado, Battlefield Earth, and The Wicker Man (the remake with Nicholas Cage, the original still has cult status but for an altogether different reason). The reigning king of this category is Tommy Wiseau’s The Room, a film so crap it will make you question your confidence in western civilisation. Some cult films are just plain weird. They push the limits of logic and make you reconsider your sanity. The horror films of Dario Argento fall into this category alongside Alejandro Jodorowsky’s work, David Lynch’s early offerings. Ed Wood, David Cronenberg and Sam Ramis’ film also frequent this category. Special mention goes to the 1977 film House (or Hausu if you are watching in its original Japanese) The English language is ill-equipped to express how bizarre this film is, so I shall recall Wittgenstein: “Whereof one cannot speak thereof one must pass over in silence.” Some cult films were box office bombs only to find love and appreciation on the shelves of Blockbusters across the country, that great lost relic of the 1990s. Donnie Darko, The Princess Bride, and Withnail and I are apt examples. 

Cult films escape the purview of popular culture, they are needles in the cultural haystack that only a select few know are there. 

The examples above are sufficient for giving cult films their cult status, but not necessary. There are two essential features however that do appear to give a film its cult status, both of which have been swallowed by steaming platforms and forever lost in memories (like tears in the rain).  

The first feature of any true cult film is rarity. There was a time when cult films were synonymous with midnight screenings and the battered video tape copies handed from die-hard fan to die-hard fan with the words “you have to watch this” muttered with every exchange. In other words, you had to actively seek the cult film, the cult film would not just magically appear on your television or on your local cinema screen because cult films are not popular. Because it is in the interests of executives to appeal to as big an audience as possible, only the biggest franchise hits will stain the Saturday afternoon listings in the hope of boosting advert revenues with their vacuous presences and meaningless narratives. Endless reruns of Harry Potter. Infinite James Bond sequels. Cult films escape the purview of popular culture, they are needles in the cultural haystack that only a select few know are there. 

This is where the second aspect enters the equation: the community. The cult film is a cult film because of the community surrounding it, or as the name suggests, a cult following. These are fans who are united in their journey to indulge in the weird, to conquer the kitsch, to resist the pangs of the culture industry. It is what drives them to attend midnight screenings, sometimes dressed as their favourite characters in the case of the Rocky Horror Picture Show. It is what drives them to have one liners etched in the grey matter of their brains readily available to whip out when the situation demands (excerpts from Withanil and I will forever echo in university halls, student house parties, and any situation that demands “finest wines available to man”) only for a bunch of troglodytes to stare blankly in aporia having not understood the reference. 

One no longer has no crowd into a dark room surrounded by total strangers to watch a cult film 

In the age where everything can be streamed, the cult film virtually stands shoulder to shoulder with the mass produced culture industry sequels and the familiar big budget Hollywood blockbuster, equally readily available to be consumed. Cult films are no longer a rarity that have to be actively sought. They are just there, waiting to be watched alongside everything else. This is exacerbated by the internet and social media sites that tirelessly revive cult films from the murky depths, illuminating them for all to see through vulgar top ten lists and film blogs. In bringing cult films to the forefront of popular consciousness, the community, once united by rarity, has now dissipated. One no longer has no crowd into a dark room surrounded by total strangers to watch a cult film. Instead, you can indulge from the comfort of your sofa, alone and pathetic. 

Are cult films dead? More or less. Admittedly their spectre lives on with increasingly rare midnight screenings which will undoubtedly become even rarer post COVID. But even so, these experiences will only serve as nostalgia for a bygone era. As critical theorist Theodor Adorno wrote:

“The culture industry is not the art of the consumer but rather the projection of the will of those in control onto their victims. The automatic self-reproduction of the status quo in its established forms is itself an expression of domination.”

Image: Free-Photos from Pixabay