The dangers of vaccine passports at universities

By Laetitia Eichinger

News recently broke that the government had begun debating the implementation of vaccine passports specifically for universities. This would mean that only double-jabbed students would be permitted to live in halls of residence and attend lectures. Given the existing level of disagreement within the Tory party on the wider issue of using vaccine passports in different areas of society, the fact that this proposal caused uproar is wholly unsurprising.

The BBC reported a short while later that it understood that the idea of requiring vaccine passports for universities had been shelved. Besides the growing discontent amongst Tory backbenchers, the decision not to discuss this idea further was primarily due to legal concerns, since university offers are legally binding. There were also practical concerns because universities are largely independent bodies and such a policy would have been near impossible to regulate.

Universities are largely independent bodies and such a policy would have been near impossible to regulate

I, like many others I am sure, was extremely relieved to hear that the idea had been parked. This is not because I am anti-vax. Quite on the contrary, I staunchly believe that anyone who is able to take up the opportunity to be inoculated should do so as soon as possible. The key phrase here is able to. What appalled me about the discussion of vaccine passports for universities was not the idea that young people ought to get vaccinated, but the complete lack of consideration for the fact that there is any number of reasons why somebody may be unable to get vaccinated.

The most common and intuitive of these, and one that, granted, was apparently discussed by the Government, is that international students may struggle to access jabs in their home countries. A vaccine passport policy, therefore, would have risked creating barriers and red-tape for international students, on top of complex travel restrictions still in place across the world. This would have been very difficult to justify to affected students, or the universities trying to support them.

A vaccine passport policy, therefore, would have risked creating barriers and red-tape for international students

Of course, there are also those who have been medically advised not to get jabbed, and a policy such as this risks being extremely discriminatory towards people who fall into this group. But what I have never seen any discussion of in the media is the fact that some people have personal and familial relations that are at stake due to the issue of vaccination.

With anti-vax and conspiratorial sentiments getting louder, it has to be fully appreciated, particularly by the government, that some people may be left in a position where they risk the serious fracturing of familial relations, or even exile from a family if they are forced to accept a vaccine. This can be despite the fact that they may personally be very keen to get vaccinated. It simply has to be left up to each individual to decide whether the benefits of getting vaccinated outweigh the risks and, in such a complex situation, the individual may very validly feel that the risks to themselves are greater.

Of course, vaccine passports are also going to be used in different areas of society, and with good reason. Implementing vaccine passports in venues such as nightclubs will surely be an excellent way of encouraging young people to accept the vaccine. The benefit to public health, in the context of nightclubs, surely outweighs the risks of potentially violating the individual freedom of those who feel unable to accept the vaccine.

Education is one of the most fundamental of rights within our society

But vaccine passports for education are a different matter entirely. Education is one of the most fundamental of rights within our society, and the government’s suggestion of erecting barriers to this, without full appreciation of the different situations in which students may find themselves, is morally unjustifiable. With an ever-growing number of students taking up the vaccine in any case, the risks of violating the right to education, even if it is just for a minority of people, is utterly unfounded.

Whatever sentiments one might have about the general use of vaccine passports in society are simply irrelevant to this matter. Under no circumstance should a barrier specific to education be considered, at least, that is, without the fullest appreciation of the very real difficulties some people may face when it comes to getting vaccinated.

For now, I am comforted that the Government has shelved this idea, and hope that, if the idea is revisited in future, the full spectrum of difficulties that people may encounter when choosing whether or not to get vaccinated will be taken into account.

Image: Diana Parkhouse via Unsplash