The danger of protectionism
When Gordon Brown used the jingoistic phrase “British jobs for British workers” in the 2007 Labour conference, it was merely a ‘dog whistle’ attempt to muster support for his regime. Meant to be a catchy soundbite, it has come back to haunt Brown in spectacular fashion.
These strikes are essentially concerned with the preference of foreign labour over a local workforce. They symbolise a desire throughout the country for British workers to be employed within Britain, hypocritically ignoring the fact that, in real terms, more Britons are employed overseas than there are foreigners employed in Britain.
It is a worrying sign that ‘Protectionism’, an inward-looking economic approach more commonly associated with the Great Depression of the 1930s, has crept into the national psyche.
While the UK has traditionally been greatly attached to free trade, as it has suited us in the past, the current economic crisis and supposed failure of liberal capitalism could lead this to change.
However, it is not just in Britain that this change is happening. The ‘Buy American’ clauses in Mr Obama’s new $800 billion rescue package sends, according to The Economist, “a disastrous signal to the rest of the world.” Alongside this, India has recently banned the importing of all Chinese toys.
In France, Russia, Greece and Latvia there have been demonstrations against their governments handling of the financial crisis. Geer Haarde has been forced to resign as Prime Minister of Iceland.
While the practice of protectionism is generally seen as, in the words of Peter Mandelson, a “huge mistake”, it is the nationalistic element which accompanies it which makes it such a danger to existing governments.
The BNP has latched onto Brown’s phrase, telling voters that “when we say it, we mean it”. They have been active on the picket lines, handing out leaflets and canvassing support.
While UNITE, the union behind the strikers, insist that they are striking against discrimination against British workers, there is more than a faint whiff of xenophobia emanating from the whole affair.
Whether these strikes were started with a nationalistic agenda in mind or not, they have now become a focus for that kind of sentiment. The strikes have grown to symbolise something far more important than they could ever have hoped to have been in themselves.
These extreme economic conditions threaten to lead to a world in which radical parties promising strong government can flourish, as shown after the great depression. Nigel Farage, leader of UKIP, is suddenly receiving far more airtime than usual, while the BNP are increasing their number of representatives in local councils all the time.
The far right has an astonishing amount of support throughout continental Europe. In Switzerland, the far right is in government. In Austria, Belgium, Denmark, France and Italy, nationalist and anti-immigrant parties regularly receive more than 10% of the vote. In Norway it is 20%.
While it would be alarmist to say that the recession is inevitably turning us all into fascists, it is highly likely that the nation’s politics as a whole will lead increasingly to a demand for stronger government. However, as regards “British jobs for British workers”, the British government currently does not have the power to rectify the situation.
As a member of the EU, Britain necessarily accepts the principle of free movement of labour and hence is, legally, unable to back up Brown’s claim with any positive action. This is why it was such a foolish thing to say: he was making an impossible promise which could only play into his opponent’s hands, because it would be impossible for the UK to follow a protectionist economic program wihout breaking EU law.
While this might sound re-assuring, it gives rise and credence to those voices advocating withdrawal from the EU. While many commentators see this as a foolish course to take, it is a course likely to appeal to the common voters: they who have been ousted from their jobs at Lindsey by, in one striker’s words, “Eyeties and Portuguese”.
Suddenly these fringe parties are no longer embarassing blips on our political radar. The recession has changed them from political non-entities to factions which, while obviously still a long way from having any political sway, need to be taken seriously. It would be historically naive not to.
