The credit crunch makes a career in the City a lot less appealing
The credit crunch has hit just about everyone in the City hard. Retail banks, investment banks, brokers and dealers, and even recruitment agencies have either seen spiralling costs or a sharp downturn in trade. The supposedly infallible Citi Group has reported losses of £5.1bn for the first quarter of 2008, the Royal Bank of Scotland are planning a rights issue of around £5-12bn to replenish their balance sheet, while UBS are busy filing a report to regulators explaining how they have managed to incur losses equivalent to the GDP of a small country.
The cause was the universal miss pricing of risky sub-prime debt, which was promptly repackaged and hedged against more equally risky sub-prime debt, and then bought and sold by almost every bank in the Western world. When the American economy turned, the sub-primers defaulted and the value of the debt was reduced to only a fraction of what it was thought to be worth—hence the term ‘write-down’.
The thing is, no one in the City really knows who owns what and how much or whether worsening economic conditions will lead to even more defaults. The result is that banks do not want to lend to each other; in fact, they are absolutely terrified of lending to anyone. This, quite simply, threatens the stability of the whole financial system. Even blue-chip companies are having trouble acquiring loans and, when they do, they get them on much less favourable terms than before.
So far the biggest casualty has been the high-flying investment banker or stockbroker. Credit Suisse have axed around 85 employees in its fixed income division, Deutsche Bank have cut around 400 jobs in various divisions in Europe and the USA, and Barclays Capital jettisoned their entire CDO team. They’ve also been some big headline resignations, such as so and so and so, and so and so and so for whoever and whatever. Graduate recruitment has dramatically reduced at most investment banks, and those with a summer internship promised will no doubt be keeping tabs on the health of financial markets in fear that they’ll be met with a retraction come September.
The story is very different, however, for law firms. They remain unphased by the credit crunch and, in contrast to almost everyone else, they are predicting strong growth for 2008. On the ground, the mood is optimistic and the credit crunch is more of a distant triviality than a question of job or no job. Firms are planning to recruit more graduates than previous years and expansion into Asia and the Middle East is going as planned. Lovells, for example, have recently opened their Dubai office to outstanding success and are pressing ahead with their Sino-Global Legal Alliance that is set to give them first-mover advantage in China.
The economic cycles of law firms do admittedly tend to operate a couple of years behind most other businesses. There is always a lag when the law is involved since legal proceedings have the habit of taking longer than expected. There is, however, something else at work in their favour. Less favourable and more expensive borrowing means higher business costs, which more than likely translates to a breach of banking covenants and bankruptcy. This is great news for a legal firm’s litigation, insolvency and restructuring teams. The work is piling up in these aptly dubbed ‘counter-cyclical’ practice areas and will only increase with the likely onset of recession. Think, for example, about the fees Slaughter and May would have charged to represent the Treasury in the Northern Rock affair. Law firms tend to work by the hour so even a no deal is a good deal as far as their cash flow is concerned.
Law firms, I am told, take a longer-term approach to recruitment and staffing. While graduates in investment banks are glorified cannon fodder, graduates cost law firms approximately £130,000 to train. After four years they have a professional qualification and the power to choose their preferred area of practice. This means, quite frankly, that law firms are in for the long haul and offer their employees the kind of job security that is mere pipe dream for an investment banker. The pay might not be as lucrative but it is far from unreasonable and, during economic downturns, one can imagine a finger or two being waved from Fleet Street across the City.
So what lessons do law firms have to offer? Diversify. The City all too often goes in for what is big today but gone tomorrow. Company boardrooms need to resist the temptation of making short-term profits by taking on too much risk. They need to stand up to shareholders, most of whom are unable to grasp the long-term view. While it is unrealistic to suggest scrapping cattle market-style graduate recruitment schemes that dominate the City, it would also be beneficial for everyone if they took a longer-term approach to their most valuable resource. Failing that, perhaps we should all become lawyers.
