The clutch of the Dark Academia aesthetic
By Regulus Spriggs-White
Academic devotion, brilliant minds and the never-ending pursuit of knowledge have found a home in Dark Academia novels, brought to popularity by Donna Tartt’s The Secret History, and have grown to permeate social media in recent years. The glorification of learning and embracing literature is a central element of the trend and in itself not problematic. In fact, many Durham students may find a sense of familiarity in the classical studies, cobblestones, and ancient architecture of Dark Academia novels, however, the trend has grown far beyond a literary trend or genre.
As a trend, Dark Academia gained attention after it emerged on Tumblr in 2015, with its popularity growing amongst young adults and adolescents in the late 2010s and early 2020s. Its return to popular culture was aided by its rise in popularity during the COVID-19 pandemic, perhaps due to the nostalgia for in-person education, or the desire for comfort and reassurance as students returned to in-person schooling after isolation, and migrated to other social media platforms as interest in it grew. Now, ‘#darkacademia’ has over 511 thousand posts on TikTok, and over 2.6 million posts on Instagram, demonstrating the intensity of its rise to fame.
Many Durham students may find a sense of familiarity in the classical studies, cobblestones and ancient architecture of Dark Academia novels
We see aesthetic photographs and motivational quotes, but less talked about is the impact the trend has on young people. As many characters are those who study the classics, and romanticise a time in which upper-class society greatly emphasised liberal education, reading, writing and the arts, we see an increase in the number of young people turning to literature and the classics, placing value on understanding them in a way that others may not. Young people following the Dark Academia aesthetic place a high value on the pursuit of knowledge and, as such, participate in activities which are portrayed in Dark Academic literature, such as museum and library visits, with education being greatly important.
Academia is not just a required part of life for those following a Dark Academia aesthetic, rather it is central and deeply valued. In Dark Academia, it is common to see a romanticised and idyllic university life with leather-bound books and yellow pages, traditional academic wear and classic or gothic architecture. Those interested in the aesthetic are more likely to seek out higher education in a location where they can find an experience which resembles these depictions despite their glamourised state.
Depictions of school and education in Dark Academia can be perceived as both positive and negative. The university environment is inherently challenging, and many of these challenges are addressed in Dark Academia novels. In particular, for students first attending university or a new school, there is often anxiety around finding a sense of belonging, which many Dark Academia novels address. The main character often feels out of place and alone, much like many real students, and question whether they belong, ultimately overcoming this vulnerability by becoming part of a close-knit group of fellow students. The genre helps students understand the importance and meaningfulness of true friendships, providing a sense of comfort as the characters face similar challenges to their own, managing to come out on the other side.
On the other hand, the intense focus on academics can be harmful, and many Dark Academia novels can be seen as promoting a toxic academic lifestyle. Characters pull all-nighters and subsist on coffee to dedicate themselves to their studies, and the reader, in turn, can be made to feel that such unhealthy practices are not only normal, but desirable for those who truly care about their education. These novels romanticise a dysfunctional side of academia which centres around toxicity and overworking, which is harmful with excessive application of this aesthetic in being detrimental to their mental and physical health. Criticism about this issue is considered, in part, responsible for the development of the subculture Light Academia which is a softer, and more emotional opposite, a less intense version of the trend.
Yet problems with Dark Academia don’t stop at these romanticised portrayals of overworking and mental illness. The novels in this genre are problematic in many ways, perhaps the most obvious is the elitism which comes from a heavy focus on prestigious boarding schools, and universities as part of the Dark Academia experience. There are characters within them who come from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, and want to belong in the elite universities they find themselves in, but they are unsure that they ever will. Richard in Tartt’s The Secret History is a great example of this, as well as Ann in Katy Hays’ The Cloisters, who both face additional challenges due to their class.
There is also a distinct lack of diversity, and a particularly noticeable exclusion of Black, Indigenous and people of colour which many have become aware of in more recent years. Whilst this is not a new issue in literature, it is potentially more harmful in Dark Academia because of the idealisation and highly regarded history of the organisations within the novels.
The intense focus on academics can be harmful, and many Dark Academia novels can be seen as promoting a toxic academic lifestyle
However, through this lack of diversity in early Dark Academia literature, we can see the growth of the genre and how young people are making it their own. As a genre, Dark Academia has a unique opportunity to raise awareness of and tackle oppressive and harmful systems in academia, and many authors have already begun doing this. In R.F. Kuang’s 2022 book Babel, we meet Robin, Ramy and Victoire who are all students from minority backgrounds, and are a clear representation of this tackling of oppression. Their worry about belonging is validated by their experiences of bias and prejudice, which highlight the ‘hidden curriculums’ many students face at university – especially those from non-white or non-traditional backgrounds. These ‘hidden curriculums’ are the unspoken norms and expectations which are often taken for granted, as information all students have access to, and those who don’t are made to feel like they are less likely to perform as well as their more informed counterparts.
M.L. Rio’s If We Were Villains includes a gay character which is uncommon in Dark Academia novels as well as addressing a different challenge for characters who worry they aren’t intelligent enough. In Rio’s work, drama student Joe faces a great amount of unease which comes from the feeling of being second best. He describes feeling “doomed to always play supporting roles in someone else’s story” and claims that he benefits from his roommate’s almost excessive popularity rather than his own friendships. Both of these themes and narratives in Dark Academia books can help to identify and increase awareness of the various structures and biases within universities and students which can be harmful and speaks to the growth the genre has had over the years.
Not only is this change in approach depicted in new authors but also in posts by those embracing a Dark Academia aesthetic which highlights what the trend should be and makes it an ultimately healthier experience for those applying such an aesthetic to their studies or wider life. With these changes, the trend is only spreading and growing in popularity. With the increased social media presence, Dark Academia is no longer just a literary trend but a lifestyle aesthetic which has permeated music, fashion, home decor and many other areas of life. Many are finding comfort and motivation in applying the aesthetic and young people are not only idealising and embracing the trend but fully embodying it. It is no longer just a genre or aesthetic and is instead a mindset of many younger generations as they embark on their next big life journey.
Image credit: Thomas Tomlinson

