The City Life

By Kimberley Carstens

Ladies, are you headed to work in London? Working in the City still isn’t as rosy as you think.

Perhaps you have attended a Durham Society event and found yourself a contact at an asset management firm? Or perchance you met multiple investment banks for an International Women’s Day Networking event who encouraged bright women like you to apply to graduate opportunities? Or maybe you just applied to a host of firms and ended up in the City?

No-one admits to the day to day challenges of being a woman in a male-dominated business environment

Thanks to headlines like “Why Women-Led Companies Are Better For Employees” (Forbes, 2019), “Women should hold quarter of top jobs at major businesses,” (Guardian, 2016) and “Government announces review into women being held back in business” (Telegraph, 2018) you knew that as a woman, you have a technical application advantage. Firms WANT women to accept their offers. They want you!

Up until now, it seems like there are opportunities for women everywhere. But in reality, the challenges of actually living up to these ambitions prove much harder than you might think. No-one admits to the day to day challenges of being a woman in a male-dominated business environment.

Controversial opinion: women have it harder in the City. Why? I’ve got three key points: opportunities, respect and culture.

Firstly, women still need opportunities to progress up the career ladder into leadership positions. In 2019, most, if not all firms are working to create a culture of diversity by implementing internal policies and incentives supporting women who want to advance their career in business and finance. Examples of this are FinnCap’s Women Leader’s Series that works to support women-led scale up businesses, Clifford Chance’s gender networking initiatives, and even Goldman Sachs pledged as much as $500 million to fund more female entrepreneurs and investors through an initiative called “Launch with GS”.

Controversial opinion: women have it harder in the City

Yet, a survey at a top financial advisor and broker on the Alternative Investment Market revealed that a big challenge that women in business face is the “lack of women in leadership positions today.” 41.6% of respondents thought that the most important initiative that a business can participate in to encourage women to progress in their career is “opportunity to progress” and “inspiration/mentorship”.

The number of female chief executives in the Fortune 500 has declined by 25% in 2018

The lack of women in leadership positions in 2019 can be attributed to the fact that “20-30 years ago there were fewer initial applications from women, fewer relevant job offers to women, and very limited support for women who wanted to share their parental responsibilities with their male partners.” Yet it has left a damaging legacy in which only 22% of UK senior roles in 2018 are held by women (up from 19% in 2017) (Grant Thornton Women in Business Report, 2018).

Furthermore, the number of female chief executives in the Fortune 500 has declined by 25% in 2018 according to the New York Times. To encourage more women to progress their career in business and finance, firms need more women in leadership positions to inspire others, but this, in turn, requires the support systems (such as childcare) for women to take more responsibility within the firm; however, this is a slow process, so during your internship don’t be surprised to see few women calling the shots.

Another very real challenge is respect in the workplace

Another very real challenge is respect in the workplace. One way that both men and women garner respect in the boardroom and business environment is through appearance. Don’t believe me? I found myself stood in heels for two hours in a casual client drinks meeting,  a meeting where I, as an intern, was the only woman. It was a meeting of eight. While perhaps I should have dismounted into cute flats (I had no idea it would be a standing event), what really struck me is that I was literally standing in a meeting dominated by men who hardly have to consider what footwear (or cut of clothes) to wear out.

Firms need more women in leadership positions to inspire others, but this in turn requires the support systems

More formally, in correspondence with Erica Young, director at investment and advisory firm Anthemis, it was shocking to learn that in order to be taken seriously, she wears glasses to important meetings due to cognitive biases that smarter people wear them. This is an issue for both genders, not necessarily exclusive to women, that one must look a certain way to be perceived as smarter and taken seriously. Further, Polly McMaster co-founded the fashion label “The Fold” to provide women with the same level of gravitas as a man in his bespoke suit. While planning your work clothes for your 8-week internship, no doubt you’ll be fighting the inherent pressure that “you cannot wear the same outfit twice in a week.”

Perhaps it’s not the biggest challenge, but what you wear is how you prove that you are serious about your job. To become a professional, you have to dress like a professional.

Now fast-forward 10 years. You’ve completed your internship, moved up the career ladder, jumped through hoops to get to where you are today, and you want to raise a family. Yet another hoop to jump through is your desire to be taken seriously while balancing parental obligations, which mostly, although not always, fall to women. Don’t be easily fooled by “flexible working hours” because your client meeting has been probably rescheduled for “home time” and now you’re faced with the trade-off between family and work commitments.

My key point is that despite the support your firm may provide, it will be harder to be taken seriously at work while balancing parental responsibilities. A survey of 24 participants (1:1 male-female ratio) revealed that 41.7% feel that childcare/family support would be the most successful measure to encourage women to progress in their career, suggesting that the support available now can still be improved upon.

Yet another hoop to jump through is your desire to be taken seriously while balancing parental obligations

It’s not fair, but it’ll be up to you to find a work culture that allows you to fulfil your commitments at work and home. This is a challenge that women (and men) face in the City, nationally and internationally and granted, working in a bigger firm may reduce childcare obstacles. Yet actually reaching the stage of accepting the job offer at such a flexible firm can prove a challenge for many.

A final fact you’ll no doubt face on your internship in London is “old boys’/lad” culture. Despite the glossy pages of your internship prospectus sharing the fantastic representation, attitude and culture towards women at *insert firm name here*, you will find a prevalent lad culture. For example, friends of mine have been told after accepting their internship that the “old boys’ culture” is definitely real in the City.

“Too much of UK business is still geared up for men, in terms of its social habits, its small talk, its clubbiness”

Moreover, conversations with several women in finance reveal that this culture exists, making integration within teams and with clients a complex task for women. According to Carolyn Fairbairn, Head of the Confederation of British Industry, a women’s career progression can also be hindered because “too much of UK business is still geared up for men, in terms of its social habits, its small talk, its clubbiness”. The associated social capital with the “lad” culture cements existing relationships, making it harder for women to establish meaningful networks in the workplace. From my own personal experience, I can certainly support her small talk point. It must be said that many jobs in the City, in finance, law, consultancy and business have been traditionally filled by men, and the culture is therefore naturally male-dominated.

So ladies, if you happen to want to head for drinks on a Friday, prepare yourself for bars swarming with men in suits similar to a college bar rugby social.

To echo Kirsten Hall, our progressive society celebrates the achievements of women in business, because ‘women in business’ are seen as high achieving exceptions rather than the norm. I want to enter the workplace where your gender is as significant as eye colour or shoe size, and I want both men and women to be valued on their ability and merit.

Our progressive society celebrates achievements of women in business, because ‘women in business’ are seen as high achieving exceptions rather than the norm

Ultimately, the endgame for both men and women is being able to walk into a boardroom, without noticing whether the people around the table are male or female. However, business hubs still remain from decades of male-dominated approaches to business in terms of perceptions, social constructs and traditions. This vision is far from what the City is today.

As university students, soon to be graduates, we have begun to play this endgame. We have the opportunity to go into the City and continue to implement this vision like the women before us have begun. You are one step closer to raising awareness that women in business are normal rather than the exception.

Ladies, you have your foot in the internship door.  Prepare yourself for your first day. Conduct a reality check. You are one step closer to overcoming the everyday challenges the City woman faces. But to overcome them, you will no doubt experience them. Perhaps not at your internship this summer, but you will face at least one of these challenges during your career life in the City.

 

Acknowledgements

With thanks to finnCap, specifically Samantha Smith, Michelle Woodger, Rhys Williams, Malar Velaigam, Kate Bannatyne and all who shared their thoughts on this issue and participated in my survey. I thank Erica Young at Anthemis who was willing to share her experiences and opinions. Finally, I thank Anders Høe Strømmen for meticulous editing and fresh perspectives on my ideas.

 

Image by Stuart Burns1