The changing relationship between faith and fiction

by Priyanka Hutschenreiter

Just as religion is inextricably woven into our lives, so is it in literature. There is no defined formula for the treatment of religion in literature, making it an oft-returned to theme that is repeatedly redefined and reinterpreted.

Philip Pullman’s latest novel The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ is a modern example of a work of literature dealing with religion. More specifically, Pullman deals with Christianity and the founding of its institution, the Church, focusing on the story of Jesus Christ.

He retells the origins of Jesus by giving him a twin brother, Christ. The former is the prophet who was good and spread good, attainable ideals of how to lead a virtuous life, while the latter is capable of all the miracles spoken of in the original story, and is convinced of forming a higher institutional order, which his brother rejects. They are both flawed characters, Jesus often reacting rashly and Christ displaying naĂŻve and conniving attributes.

Pullman is widely known as an atheist so his work may be an extreme example of modern literary treatments of religion – unsurprisingly The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ has been condemned by many Christians as blasphemous.

However, there are  several other examples of controversial modern literature dealing with religion. George Orwell’s 1984, for instance, represents the theme of a godless world constructed upon totalitarian lines, while Aldous Huxley’s The Devils of Loudun represents a world where a religion is intolerant of other religions or the infringement of its rules of behaviour.

In comparison, Pullman’s novel takes a different approach, reinterpreting an existing religious story. In a discussion aired on BBC Radio 4 in April, Pullman explained his approach to the novel, declaring that his object was to narrate his own interpretation of the gospels, deliberately refraining from reading the work of Jesus scholars.

In The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ, Pullman evaluates the gospels in a different light and, though it is indubitably controversial, it cannot be seen as a heinous attack on faith. Pullman treats the story of Jesus Christ as a myth, not fact. However, it is important to note that Pullman does not exclude supernatural forces from the story as Mary is impregnated by an angel, while the child Christ performs miracles to save his brother from trouble.

Indeed, Pullman’s past work is very much engaged in fantasy and the supernatural. Thus, to him, the gospels are stories, which can be reinterpreted over and over, and do not have to be seen as the truth. Ultimately Pullman strips the institution of its veil of idealization, and also creates Jesus as a realistic character, as a man – a hero, but a man nonetheless.

Pullman’s new book is undoubtedly provocative, but he is not the first to contest established views of religion and he will not be the last. In the end, however, it could be suggested that the act of ardently arguing a cause in literature, as Pullman advocates atheism, is a faith in itself.