The case for secularism – we should be celebrating Darwin, not listening to DICCU

It’s that time of year again. As you are probably aware, next week the DSU plays host to a series of events from the Durham Inter-Collegiate Christian Union, DICCU, inviting us to consider the claims of Jesus.

What is less well known is that this week of events is one of hundreds occurring at universities across the country at around this time of year. DICCU is part of a global student evangelical movement, originating in the International Fellowship of Evangelical Students, founded in Oxford in the 1930s, with a UK branch that is a network for student evangelism in the UK.

Along with SAUCU, UMCU, OICCU, CICCU and all the other beautiful acronyms, the Durham branch will be distributing free copies of the gospel of Mark, repackaged in an “accessible and contemporary-looking” form, “ideal for both personal evangelism and large-scale events.” This booklet declares that the true, eye-witness account of Jesus is “a secret they’ve tried to silence.”

They, presumably, are the godless establishment, the secular forces in history which have conspired against our only chance for moral purity and eternal life. Often in Christian history they have been the Jews, and for some people they still are. I once visited a mosque’s exhibition on Islam, only to be accosted by one of the organisers for a discussion about God. When I brought evolution by natural selection into the argument, he told me with complete earnestness that Darwin was a Jew and so not to be trusted.

I don’t think this man was hateful: I think he was deluded. He had convinced himself that Islam was the answer to all his problems, that his god would free him from life. The daily disappointment of the real world therefore required explanation, which led him to suppose that diabolical forces were at work against him and against his truth. As the Nazis might have put it, the ‘Jewish science’ of Marx, Freud and Einstein represents a threat to old certainties.

Darwin, of course, was neither Jewish nor an agent of Satan. He was a conscientious, humble genius who radically contributed to the history of ideas. According to a recent biography, that of Prof. James Moore and Prof. Adrian Desmond, Darwin was partly motivated to investigate the descent of man by his wish to demonstrate that all humans are essentially of one family. At the time, a common argument justifying slavery and imperialism was that the peoples of the earth were different species, and so European men need not treat others as equals. Darwin’s theory entails a universalism about human nature that has the social benefit of smashing parochial excuses for racism.

A century and a half later, we find ourselves amid a resurgence of religious fundamentalism, which brings with it both the threat of theocracy and the division of peoples by religious identity. I simply did not expect to come to university and see hundreds of students listening to talks explaining, in the nicest possible tone, that Hell is a real place where you go if you do not put faith in Jesus. This evening, the Union Society will be hosting a debate on whether ‘intelligent design’ should be taught in science classes, and it is frankly shocking that there are three academics in the world willing to argue that it should.

It’s not faith in God or hope for an afterlife that’s problematic, nor is it a love and respect for religious traditions and ideas. It is fundamentalism: it is the mentality of those who are certain not only that God exists, but that through the reading of Holy texts we have access to His mind and His plan for us. So far this year, DICCU talks have told us (as usual, with immense and admirable friendliness) that God hates homosexuality and that Catholicism is not a route to salvation. This does not make DICCU members equivalent to homophobic bullies or anti-Catholic bigots: it makes them gentle and kind individuals who appear to be convinced that it is their job to inform us that we are damned unless we come to believe what nobody could possibly know.

The central epistemological weakness of this self-confidence becomes in addition its social poison. DICCU claim to know through historical revelation where salvation lies. The same method is open to any other group who have a similarly grandiose claim. As soon as religion enters politics, this difficulty becomes disastrous. The Baha’i in Iran believe that a nineteenth century figure added to the revelation of the Koran, for which heresy they have been subject to mob justice and executions by the Shi’a theocratic government. The Baha’i are roughly equivalent to Mormons in America, with the important difference that in America secularism is enshrined in the constitution. No sensible person could want Mitt Romney to be President of the US, but that he should not be barred from running because of his faith is unquestionable.

Every day we should thank Heaven that we live in a society which does not give significant privilege to any revelation-based community. I don’t have any particular objection to DICCU being allowed to evangelise in our student union, though it would be nice if they ran forums of debate instead of explanatory talks. I just wish that celebration of Darwin, on his two hundredth anniversary this week, could be as prominent in our community of learning as evangelism is every year.