The British Bill of Rights: a risk too far
Last week, as David Cameron re-announced plans for a British Bill of Rights, serious concerns continued to spread in political and legal circles about the changes. This follows a number of ill-conceived proposals introduced by Cameron in past months to appease angered members of his party.
The Bill of Rights has been proposed by the Conservatives for quite some time, but Cameron’s sudden revival of the idea, coupled with a lack of clarity over its contents, is very concerning. Legislating radically and without thought to try and avoid further division within the party, the Conservatives are not in any position to write effective legislation, let alone meddle with one of this country’s most important laws. It is clear that any changes will have potentially catastrophic effects on human rights law, especially on the rights of the individuals and minorities against the state.
It’s certainly very controversial politically: since the original call by Cameron back in 2007, the plans have been looked at by a commission, which was unable to reach a consensus, and were then shelved by the Tories after they admitted they did not have the numbers to push the bill through Parliament. The Scottish Parliament has already started that it will refuse to implement the Bill if passed in Westminster.
The plans, however, have once again reared their ugly head, due to increased calls to leave the EU and for tougher measures against suspected terrorists, from within the Conservative party. Unfortunately, as seeming to represent European meddling in British affairs, and even worse, European meddling on our terror measures, the European Convention on Human Rights, through the Human Rights Act, has also come into the firing line. This follows a series of high profile cases, such as the inability of the Government to extradite Abu Quatada, which have riled both the Conservatives and the public.
Thus we come to the core idea of the Government’s proposals: To maintain the current Convention rights, but to be able to over-rule the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg. It sounds a reasonable proposal. However, when one looks closer, serious and worrying implications appear, which the Conservatives seem to have merrily overlooked in their rage at European meddling. The first issue is what one’s rights actually are under the European Convention.
For several years, the Court of Human Rights has gradually expanded its definition of the areas it can judge on, for example into police search’s and prisoner voting. Many Conservatives wish to restrict, to varying degrees, the areas to which the Bill will apply back to the original written rights. However, this would greatly nullify the practical use of the Bill. We have to recognize that times are different from 1950 when the Convention was signed, when there were still dictatorships in Europe, and the UK has ratified very few meaningful changes to the Convention since then. Today, though some original areas, especially those to do with freedom of religion, are currently well-used, others such as torture, are well-established and taken for granted by both sides. Instead, the current issues of contention regard the smaller details, like prisoner voting, which are unclear. The law, through the judgments of Strasbourg has evolved to reflect that.
The fundamental issue is, however, that this method of operation directly undermines the entire system of UK Human Rights legislation. The entire idea is that the minority cannot be completely controlled by the majority, to prevent a tragic event like the Holocaust happening again. It is a noble idea. However, by giving Parliament (the majority) the ability to completely over-rule Human Rights decisions, as well as to pick and choose which cases actually make it to Court in the first place, totally abolishes the entire system. Furthermore, whilst it may look innocent enough whilst we remain on the side of the majority, as we do in many cases, it is an uncomfortable leap towards the inception of an Orwellian dystopia.
It is clear then that Cameron is risking political backlash, constitutional crisis and the very nature of the State just to placate a few angered members of his party. However, there is hope. This is an excellent opportunity to streamline the court process and to even increase the amount of domestic Human Rights legislation, if someone can be trusted to do it properly without destroying the rich law we already have. The problem is, that’s not a role I would trust to politicians.
Photograph – UK Department for International Development

