‘The Brinkley Girl’ and the making of the modern woman

By Lydia Lovell

The Roaring Twenties was a period of opulence, excess, and luxury following the bleak years of the First World War. In Western culture, the pinnacle of this luxury pertained to the emergence of lifestyle and culture magazines. Life in the post-war atmosphere became personal and selfish again, and obsessive with the cult of celebrity. As such, the wealthy middle-class sought leisure and stimulation in the need for an image, something to modify their own look, something to push them artistically and socially. It was now a time when newspapers and magazines began to hold more than just ‘news’ – they became the most mainstream form of daily consumerism and entertainment. One of the most influential contributors to this period of both artistic and social development was author and illustrator – the ‘Queen of Comics’ – Nell Brinkley. Her work became part of a ‘nouveau’ image culture for young women in particular, forcing them to consolidate, as Rachael Alexander states, ‘a renegotiation of the relationship between appearance and identity.’ 

The modern woman refused to retreat back into her pre-war position

Young, beautiful, and rich American women began to borrow from magazine culture and dress themselves from the pages – taking a new slice of identity with them. Brinkley’s work, for example, appeared in Journal, and boosted the newspaper’s circulation, showcasing the impact of illustrative image on the dissemination of trend and media. Her emergence coincided with the development of the radio, where most news was now released, but preceded the development of photography. Art and illustration was, therefore, the forefront of lifestyle and the archetype for which, women in particular, led their lives by. Preceding magazines covered by artists such as Jessie Willcox Smith reinforced a William Blake-esque quality of ‘innocence’, and an idyll of domestic family life. Whilst beautiful in a different manner, these illustrations could not match the new demand for an entirely opposing culture of independence. In the past, artists attempted to capture the ideal woman in an image – something once achieved by Charles Dana Gibson and his manifestation of ‘The Gibson Girl’. She, however capturing, represented the values that came alongside the traditional domestic expectations among women – Gibson’s work consists of several images in stasis, frozen in time, in black and white – almost as if times were never going to change. Brinkley’s succession, ‘The Brinkley Girl’, unlike the Gibson Girl, was expressive, colourful, animated, and social. Brinkley was one of the first artists to fully comprise a connection between being a young and attractive woman, whilst also being involved in suffrage and social growth.

‘The Brinkley Girl’ was engaged in independent activities and was constantly in motion. Her figure almost seems like an early prototype for Barbie – Brinkley channelled for women a growing aspiration with the lack of social roles available to them in reality. It was so important for the transition of the period to have its own transition from a male-created Gibson girl to a female-created Brinkley girl – she quite literally made the modern woman. The modern woman refused to retreat back into her pre-war position – she wanted to thrive, and vote. Brinkley’s cartoons reflected modern women breaking out of the domestic sphere into adventure and fame. As such, the Brinkley Girl became a pop culture icon, appearing in music, and inspiring a line of hair curlers. She became a form of reality manifested in real women that existed, and emphasised strength. Beetham’s comment that women became ‘both purchasers and readers of texts’ proves that some form of consumerism in these magazines (often now critiqued as manipulative commercial objects) was necessary for ideas of suffrage and female independence to reach the public.

The perfect blend of Art Deco and Art Nouveau

Brinkley’s work stands out in its bright colour and attention to line and shape work. It is the perfect blend of Art Deco and Art Nouveau, with strong geometric patterns integrated into her fashion illustration combined with the iconic smooth curls of her characters. A true epitome of the era – her work is dynamic, expressive, and full of the material excess of the young rich women it is intended for. Her characters are drawn with such realism but are styled by trend; figured and shaped by freshness, innovation and modernity. Brinkley is saying with continuity – ‘look at what you could be like’ – not completely in an aesthetic way but in their feeling and freedom.

It is no surprise that Brinkley’s work coincided with the era of first-wave feminism, and the decade in which some women first received the vote in the western world. It reminds us in our own roaring twenties, whether artists or authors or contributors in whatever we do, to create representation for the people who still face disparity like the women who went unrecognisable in this era. To divert from other forms of media, towards our visual culture, is to seek out those messages of hope and progression.

Images: Nell Brinkley via Wikimedia Creative Commons