The Booker Prize longlist: ‘Burnt Sugar’ by Avni Doshi

By Rachael Pimblett

Avni Doshi’s debut novel, Burnt Sugar (titled Girl in White Cotton in India) was published by Penguin Books in August 2019 and sits on the Booker Prize longlist for 2020. The novel explores the complex relationship between mother and daughter, as unreliable memories, repressed anger and emotional avoidance from years of neglect cause a harrowing self-reflection through the unpacking of domestic history. Not only does Burnt Sugar offer a vivid, lasting depiction of Pune, India, with its wide highways and unbreathable heat, but it offers a deep dive into the unstable psyche of two difficult women. 

Doshi’s plot gives the reader everything enticing and exciting, without being too extreme and unbelievable: the psychological impacts of cult-life, the dark inhospitality of an Indian boarding school, the extremity of life as a beggar, the deterioration of a failed marriage – the list is almost endless. The jumping chronology allows memories that present-day Antara represses to flesh out into their multi-coloured selves. This also means thats, after starting with a near-obsessive focus on Antara’s mother, Antara’s psychological portrait is slowly revealed and explained, and the narration begins to look inward. I found myself hooked, searching for clues, anticipating the next piece of the puzzle that explains Antara’s unhealthy coping mechanisms in the face of her mother’s dementia. 

I found myself hooked, searching for clues, anticipating the next piece of the puzzle.

Doshi’s characterisation is surprisingly varied despite the clipped, clinical tone of narration; each character simultaneously serves a narrative purpose whilst sustaining the reader’s interest as a sum of their own parts: Antara’s friend Purvi is charming and vivacious, whilst also representing an unknowable universe for Antara and juxtaposing her own bleak reality; Purvi’s husband’s odd fascination with parasites is a sprinkle of welcome humour to the sharp-tongued and often cruel narrative. ‘a bisexual, a power-monger and a demented lady walk into a bar’. Antara is not a character created to be likeable, and sometimes the explanations Doshi inserts for her brutal behaviour do not stretch far enough to elicit reader sympathy: ‘I disown so I can never be disowned’ is overshadowed by cold-hearted streams of consciousness such as ‘there is something resourceful in consuming what clings to you’. Still, the act of creating a narrator that I aggressively disliked, but obsessively turned pages to understand, is no minor feat. Something about that pull begs us to look within ourselves, despite the twisted plot and intimate, particular details. Doshi reveals an uncomfortable universal truth: even our selfless acts can disguise selfish cruelty.

Perhaps the writing itself is the magic behind the success of Burnt Sugar. There were several sparkling moments in which I was desperate to read the quote aloud to my housemate: ‘It feels good to cry sometimes, but Dilip says that football players in America who tackle each other all day are more likely to beat their wives, so maybe only love begets love.’ This made for a highly quotable book, which grants even greater gratification through the catharsis of realising and relishing in the beauty of certain sentences. 

Perhaps the writing itself is the magic behind the success of Burnt Sugar


The importance of art (as Doshi herself was an art critic and exhibition curator) shapes the structure and narrative into something aesthetic, and the inclusion on sketching and photography adds to Doshi’s exploration of belonging, documenting history, discovering new layers within ourselves and the world, and choosing to capture moments and spaces important for the climax of the story. The misery and pessimism characterising the book can often make it a hard read, so much so that several times I had to put the book down and come back to it a few days later when I had readied myself for such heavy negativity. Burnt Sugar isn’t an easy book to curl up on the sofa with and read cover-to-cover. The words go down a treat, but the message behind them? Not so much. Having said that, I was definitely gushing to friends and family about my latest read both during and after my time with Burnt Sugar. The lasting effect of its unique tale confirms, for me at least, that this book definitely deserves its place on the longlist for the Booker Prize.

Image: Penguin Books