The Bishop of Durham should apologise for his sermon
The Right Honourable Tony Blair has recently been lecturing us on the undervalued role of religion in public life. But before we take his latest world-saving project seriously, I think a case study of religious authority is in order. For this, we must be careful to select someone who cannot be called a straw man: what better candidate than our very own Bishop of Durham?
Dr Tom Wright is a prominent theologian and senior Anglican, exercising considerable influence through his positions in the House of Lords and on the Lambeth Commission. In an interview with this newspaper (25th February), he explained the failings of populist commentators in dealing with religion, painting a general picture of the media as hasty, thoughtless and unfair in its criticisms. But exactly how fair and responsible are the Bishop’s own contributions to public life?
In his Easter sermon, Bishop Wright launched a blistering assault on the government’s fertility and embryology bill, which he claims was motivated by mythology rather than rationality: “secular utopianism is based on a belief in an unstoppable human ability to make a better world.” Bishop Wright claims, in other words, that the arguments offered in favour of the bill were merely excuses for a secularist myth which has possessed leading scientists and our (Christian) Prime Minister. It is very hard to understand how Bishop Wright, who is both intelligent and well-informed, considers this a fair representation of the position he attacks. Frankly, it sounds more like the ravings of a paranoiac. Which leaves us to speculate about the Bishop’s integrity; to borrow the phrasing of a familiar argument, are we dealing with a liar or a lunatic?
Most likely, we are dealing with the rhetoric of a Bishop who wants to rouse his flock to righteous indignation and doesn’t much care if he misrepresents quite reasonable positions in the process. The secular myth of utopia, we are told, propels the view that we have “the right to kill unborn children and surplus old people, and to play games with the humanity of those in between.” Bishop Wright has been challenged over this by David Aaronovitch of The Times, who requested to know who exactly has been arguing for the right to kill surplus old people? The Bishop’s response was first to evade the question by asking three of his own, and then to write an article on the difficult question of legalised euthanasia – which is what he meant by “the right to kill surplus old people” – though the complaint stands that this is evidently an unfair portrayal of the debatable but sane case for a change in the law.
The most obscene rhetoric, though, is yet to come. The Bishop’s arguments develop towards a witty climax: “Gender-bending was so last century; we now do species-bending. Look how clever we are! Utopia must be just round the corner.” Forgive me, Bishop, for not quite understanding how ‘gender-bending’ has anything at all to do with your topic: it seems to me extremely unlikely that those who are quite often bullied for not acting their gender are motivated either by intellectual arrogance or by a utopian political agenda. Unless the causal connection runs the other way: does Bishop Wright think effeminacy leads to militant secularism? I will submit to the reader’s best judgement whether the Bishop’s camp ‘so’ constitutes malice or harmless fun, but hearing it from a man who goes out of his way to keep the Anglican Church officially anti-gay, it’s difficult to smile.
The most delicious trick, though, was the invocation of Orwell’s dystopian fiction: “In this 1984-style world, we create our own utopia by our own efforts, particularly our science and technology.” Personally, when I read 1984 it wasn’t secularism that sent shivers down my spine, it was totalitarianism. One plausible theory for the origin of the term ‘Big Brother’, which is now so famous thanks to Endemol, is that Orwell borrowed it from Bertrand Russell’s lecture ‘Why I am not a Christian’, in which he hypothesises a key motive for religious belief: “the wish for safety, a feeling that there is a big brother who will look after you.” So it seems likely that Orwell took a dim opinion of surrendering moral responsibility to divine judgement. Yet, according to Bishop Wright, our secular age has forgotten Orwell’s anti-utopian lesson, as is evident from the wish of scientists to make life better for people. And this is a reason, presumably, why more political kudos should go to the Bishop’s own utopian mythology – it’s only fair!
On the question of the controversial research, doesn’t Bishop Wright have a point that there is something creepy about mixing human and animal matter? I don’t think so, personally, but even if you agree with him, remember that what is being proposed in the embryology bill is the decriminalisation of these experiments, not a government stamp of moral approval.
It is easy to forget that scientists are individuals with consciences like the rest of us, and are therefore free to choose not to engage in experiments that mix animal and human matter. If most medical researchers agree that these experiments should go ahead, that is probably because they are more familiar than others with the needs of patients, not because they are possessed by a demonic desire to ‘play God’ for the sake of it.
The excellent film Juno was recently met with a torrent of abuse from some who saw it as a ‘pro-life’ movie since in it, shock horror, a teenager who gets pregnant decides to keep her baby! This reaction utterly misses the power of the ‘pro-choice’ position: when it is difficult to carve nature at the ethical joints, as in the case of the moral status of a foetus, it is better to foster a culture of understanding and allow people to make their own decisions than it is to impose a solution through law.
In the case of the embryology bill, the question is whether the moral concerns raised are a strong enough reason for the state to override the choice of researchers and the interests of patients. In Bishop Wright’s opinion, they are. We know that it is also the Bishop’s opinion that Christians should regard euthanasia, homosexuality and abortion as immoral. So it is only fair that he tells us: would he vote to criminalise all these activities?
In our country, one minority religious group, the Anglican Church, is privileged by the state, which means, among other things, that Bishop Wright is allowed to vote on legislation on behalf of us all without being elected by any of us. Remind yourself of this next time you hear from the Tony Blair Faith Foundation; or next time Archbishop Williams claims that the idea of one law for everyone is “a bit of a danger”; or next time Cardinal O’Connor asserts that “atheistic secularism ultimately diminishes us;” This miasma of incoherent assaults on a supposedly militant secularism demonstrated why those who claim to know the mind of God should be kept as far from government as possible.
Sources for this article can be found on the Facebook group, The Case Against the Bishop of Durham
If Bishop Wright would like to respond, we’d be delighted to hear from him
