The Bishop of Durham: “It will be an enormous honour and privilege to be that close to our new King on the day that he’s crowned.”
Profile speaks with The Right Reverend Paul Butler about Durham, the Church of England and his role as Bishop Assistant to the Sovereign in the Coronation.
William Rome
The incumbent Bishop of Durham, the fourth most senior clergyman in the Church of England, has none of the grandiosity which his high office might suggest. He is sincere, thoughtful and unpretentious throughout our Zoom call, as he was on a previous encounter, and though deeply devout and proud of the Church’s role in society, he does not evangelize. Rather, he emphasises the importance of people being able to make up their own minds about God in an informed way and is consistently pragmatic about the problems and opportunities with which the Church of England is presented.
The Bishop grew up in Surrey, went to University in Nottingham and has spent most of his working life in the South, all as a clergyman: “I knew pretty well immediately that if I was going to follow Jesus, it had to mean all of my life.” Being invited to be Bishop of Durham – after formal interviews – was a “shock,” as was his first appointment as a Bishop, given he had “never even dreamed I’d be a Bishop.” Indeed, when a young Christian, disillusioned with the Church of England, he’d have “run a mile and said you’ve got to be joking” if asked whether he would “end up being a vicar or even a bishop.” Despite his Southern roots, County Durham and its parishioners are clearly very close to his heart.
The Bishop of Durham is always a member of the House of Lords. Consequently, national ecclesiastical and political matters occupy much of his time, but he works to ensure that “in all the national things I do, I’m able to offer examples or illustrations from the North-East itself, partly because national government can very easily forget the North-East.” Although involvement within University affairs remains the purview of the Dean of the Cathedral, the Bishop meets frequently with the Vice-Chancellor and has links with various colleges, notably as Chair of the Hild Bede Trust, whilst endeavouring “to get to at least one graduation every year.” He is also acutely aware of the issue of “severe poverty” in County Durham, to which many students, who often “get into a bit of a bubble,” are oblivious. He believes the Church can play a vital role, not only in improving town-gown relations but more importantly in “being there for all people, not only those who associate themselves with it.” He notes that “the Church can offer students a way to engage with local community issues,” praising many different churches and charities in Durham for their efforts. He also highlights St. Nic’s Church’s efforts “with overseas students, offering them welcome…[and] helping them to understand cultural issues.” For him, the Church should provide “practical support as well as spiritual guidance.”
The Church of England has always seen itself as being there for all people, not only those who associate themselves with it
The Church’s charitable role within local communities is clearly of great importance to him, perhaps unsurprising given his past work in London with young people. He is very proud of the Warm Spaces initiative in Durham, which involved 4500 different venues providing warmth and companionship over the winter but relied on the Church of England, the only institution which “had the convening power to do it.” He also highlights the Church’s extensive role in primary education, particularly in rural areas. He sees the Church as an important part of levelling-up. He assesses this project as being “about addressing inequalities…and it cannot be done by government alone”, which he praises the national government for acknowledging. National and local government efforts must be accompanied by those of local businesses, large corporations and “the voluntary charity sector and the faith communities.” This combination can give people “opportunities for themselves to grow and develop, and that might often start as a volunteer.”
The Church’s charitable involvement inevitably makes it political, to which the Bishop does not object. He observes that “if you don’t only feed the hungry but start asking questions about why are these people hungry, you’re immediately involved in a political debate.” He believes that the Lords Spiritual in particular, of which he is amongst the most senior, “play an important role in raising moral questions, arguing the case around ethics and spirituality”; inevitably government policy, simply because there is more of it, tends to receive the most critique. Yet, his involvement in politics is not limited to Westminster, as the Anglican Communion has in recent years become increasing divided over issues like gay marriage. He believes that such divisions are inevitable, but he and his fellow Bishops are “committed to work…on seeking to find ways of holding us together.”
The Bishop recognises that the number of Churchgoers has significantly decreased in recent years, particularly amongst students, which he attributes to a more secular society alongside “the pressures…[of] academic life” and the increased selection of activities with which students can occupy themselves. He praises Christian Unions, which were a great influence on him, for their ability “to give all students the opportunity to hear about the Christian faith and to make their own decisions about it.” He is also optimistic that the forthcoming Coronation will encourage people “to look afresh at the Christian faith” as it puts on display the role “the Christian faith has played in the life and history of this nation” and continues to play.
The Bishop of Durham has a crucial role in the Coronation. He and the Bishop of Bath and Wells are the Bishops Assistant to the Sovereign, which means “it’s our responsibility to escort him at every point in the service.” “We’re there to assist the sovereign in whatever way he may need.” Tradition demanded that he submit to the Court of Claims his “claim as to why I should be given this role and that was all to do with the history.” He recognises that “it’s an extraordinary honour and privilege, certainly one that this little boy from Chessington in Surrey never ever thought that he’d be doing.”
If you don’t only feed the hungry but start asking questions about why are these people hungry, you’re immediately involved in a political debate
The Coronation is also important as a Christian ceremony. He mentions on several occasions that, despite the pomp and ceremony and the emphasis placed by the King (much like the late Queen) on there being “space for other faiths and…the freedom of worship,” the ceremony is “is in the context of a Church of England communion service.” He remains coy about the role of other faiths, insisting we “wait for the Coronation itself to see in what ways other faith leaders might be involved” whilst emphasising that, this being an Anglican service, “it would be inappropriate for us to invite leaders of other faiths to do something that made them compromise their faith.”
His role in the Coronation is well deserved for a man who has diligently served his faith and the communities in which he has lived across his decades as a clergyman. He recognises how important the Church is to so many communities but does not dispute the challenges which it faces. He is very much a clergyman for the modern era – community-driven, politically astute and optimistic for the future.
Quickfire Round
Favourite Part of the Cathedral
The Feretory – Cuthbert’s Tomb
One non-religious text that you recommend
Gilead, the novel by Marilynne Robinson, or indeed the whole set of Marilynne Robinson’s Gilead group.
Any non-Biblical spiritual heroes?
Yes, but they’re all people no one would have heard of. … [It’s] quite important that actually it’s ordinary Christian people who are the ones who really inspire others.
Favourite part (particularly churches) of the Diocese of Durham
Oh, I’m not allowed to have favourites. But because of the history and the roots, Escomb Saxon Church, because it’s such a wonderful example of a Saxon Church, and St. Peter’s Monk Wearmouth, where Bede studied, because when you’re leading worship there, and you look at the door, and it’s still the door that Bede would have walked in and out of.
Photo Credits: Roger Harris, via Wikimedia Creative Commons
