The best mince pie money can buy?
By Libby Morrell
What the best part about the run up to Christmas? Decorations? Christmas movies? Participating in a Christmas social with every single club or society you’ve ever frequented? In my opinion, there is little else that gets me as excited for Christmas than the humble mice pie.
I have an unhealthy relationship with mince pies. That puts it mildly. I first came across this season’s mince pies in the middle of October and currently, at the time of writing, I have ploughed my way through 137 mince pies so far. Mince pies fulfil three important criteria: they’re cheap (rarely more than £2 a box); they fulfil cravings for both sugar and fat and they’re conveniently seasonal- by the time you start to get fed up, they’re off the shelves for another ten months.
My culinary odyssey has led me to try most of the mince pies on the market and here’s my run down.
The original mice pies were filled with meat, such as lamb, rather than the dried fruits and spices mix as they are today. They were also first made in an oval shape to represent the manger that Jesus slept in as a baby, with the top representing his swaddling clothes. During the Stuart and Georgian times, in the UK, mince pies were a status symbol at Christmas- a far cry from the 87p you need to shell out at market square Tesco’s.
So what’s the best mince pie money can buy? My culinary odyssey has led me to try most of the mince pies on the market and here’s my run down. On a student budget, the majority of my purchases have been on the budget end of the spectrum. The best pies on the peninsula can be found in Tesco; at just a pound a pop (regularly reduced to 87p), their rich buttery pastry and a perfectly spiced filling never disappoint- much to the amusement of Durham country councils recycling team who have witnessed a worrying number of boxes appear on the pavement every fortnight. Vying for second place are Aldi’s basic mince pies- almost makes living in the desert that is Gilesgate worth it.
When you are feeling a little extra special than that extra pound you can splurge on a luxury box is well worth it. Tesco’s extra special mince pies are infused with Cognac and are absolutely divine warmed up- this alongside a bottle of their cheapest plonk was my sole celebration for landing a big 4 internship and it was more than enough.
Whether you go for the 12 mini ones (chewier and more crumbly), 6 normal size ones (a much more satisfying filling to pastry ratio) or their crumble topped ones (a pleasantly surprising substitution in my Tesco direct order) depends completely on your mood. If the luxury you have is time – well worth setting aside, even in summative season – then Iceland’s ÂŁ1.20 mince pies, cooked in the comfort of your own grimy student kitchen and eaten warm, are always a safe bet.
Enjoy your festive treats and Merry Christmas!
Photograph: Daniel Morris via Unsplash
