The benefits of making money

Printing Money; If only it were that easy
Printing Money; If only it were that easy

By James Murray

Despite using it everyday few of us ask what money is and where it comes from. 

In the first Quarterly Bulletin of 2014, the Bank of England published a paper entitled “Money in the modern economy: an introduction.” The analysis confirmed the shocking truth about the nation’s money supply.

For the UK, 97% of money is created by commercial banks when they make loans, simply by typing numbers into a computer. Since the deposits are created as debt, for every pound in the economy there is a pound of debt.

Yet only 12 % of this debt is created through lending to growth-generating business. The rest is predominantly lent for mortgages and financial speculation on fixed assets that are inherently unproductive.

It is for this reason that the UK has been able to accumulate a staggeringly unmanageable ÂŁ1.439 trillion of personal debt, as of February 2014. This is a much more worrying 450 % of GDP than the national debt which is a mere 70 % of GDP.

Each year ÂŁ100-200 billion is paid to banks in interest for borrowing money the banks created for free. Under this system for there to be growth, there has to be an increase in the money supply, and for that to happen we all have to go into more debt.

For a long time the rhetoric of the Bank of England (and that of the vast majority of university syllabi) has been that banks simply re-lend the deposits of savers, expanding the money supply (amount of money in the economy) via a manageable amount according to the money multiplier model. This suggested that the Bank of England could control the total amount of money in the economy (by controlling the reserves).

However, what banks are really doing is deciding the amount of money they will lend based on the profit level they can make from this lending. Depending upon how much they lend, banks need to hold a certain amount in central bank reserves to cover our withdrawals (and inter bank settlements). The Bank of England supplies these reserves, practically on demand. In this sense, it is the banks that determine reserves, and not the other way round.

The reality is that it is the actions of banking that determines the national money supply. As a result, banks create too much money in booms, and too little in recessions.

This is not the fault of banks, as private enterprises they are as much as obliged to act this way. However, as a nation do we really want something as important as our national money supply to be determined by what is profitable for a few companies rather than what is best for the wider economy? This analysis raises some very serious questions.

Should banks be bestowed with this right to make money and charge everybody for it?

Is there not a more stable and prosperous way to run an economy that doesn’t engender suffocating indebtedness?

Who will protect the small businesses that struggle for financing through the volatility of the money supply?

Groups such as PositiveMoney, whose website hosts comprehensive material covering exactly how this process works and the inimical effects it has for the economy, have detailed simple changes that could be made to fix the system.

In doing so debt, crisis and deep recessions may be avoided. Levels of debt could be reduced to manageable-even productive amounts. It seems only right that a more accountable, democratic body is in control of this essential national asset.

Photograph: Alexey Kudenko