The beautiful game hides an ugly secret
It has been almost fifteen years since the former Nottingham Forest forward Justin Fashanu took his own life, yet he remains the only openly homosexual footballer in the history of the game.
This is a sad inditement on the country’s national sport and a shining example of its failure to tackle the taboo.
Change is undoubtedly underway in the sporting world and stars such as Gareth Thomas (Rugby) and Chris Davies (Cricket) have helped to provide a basis for cautious optimism. Yet these cases are limited and more role models of their ilk are sorely missed. This is particularly the case in football.
Chairman of the PFA, Clarke Carlisle has been approached by eight professional football players thinking of ‘coming out’. Seven of them cited worries about media reaction as the cause of their reluctance. Sportsmen should not be obliged to offer open access to their private affairs for public gratification, but at this juncture we need such figures to do more than we have any right to expect. Sport needs new heroes and heroines.
Carlisle has pointed to ‘‘base level’’ language used at all levels as a deterrent to those wishing to open up about their sexuality, but it is a lack of openness which encourages such behaviour. A crowd at a football match feels disassociated from responsibility on the terrace. I can personally recall giving match officials a torrent of abuse that would seem totally inappropriate in any other setting.
Fans don’t engage with homosexuality as a reality in sport. Discrimination is thus born out of immaturity and an evasion of the real issue.
The image of Robbie Fowler’s lurid gesturing at Graham Le Saux, the subject of unfounded rumours about his sexuality, during a 1999 league fixture reflect the level of immaturity across all levels of the game. We could and should have moved on from here but the issue has been left to fester.
If a homosexual player was honest about their private lives the football community would be forced to think again. Real, tangible examples would turn homophobia from a ‘banterous’ joke into an attack on real people living real lives.
When forced to confront it as the genuine issue it is, the majority would accept discrimination, in any form, as wrong. I honestly believe therefore that the onus is on individuals to stand up, be honest and be counted.
Indeed such individuals can take comfort from recent experience. Chris Davies did not have his life torn apart by the media but faced the reaction one would expect and demand of our society – unequivocal support, praise for taking a brave decision and ultimately a dismissal of it as anything but a personal and perfectly normal matter.
Gareth Thomas has also been in the media spotlight but this is to be expected, and indeed is needed, when you are seeking to break new ground. Surely sports like football could cope in a similar manner.
In some women’s sport the problem appears to be of an inverse nature. There is a perception that a significant number, if not the majority, of female golfers or female tennis players are lesbian, despite limited evidence to support this. Such stereotypes present different problems but come from the same place; an immature and unthinking attitude to homosexuality in the sporting world.
Sport undeniably has some deep rooted demons to expel. A recent National Union of Students survey found that only 37.8% of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender students who take part in organised sport at university were open about their sexuality with teammates. This is a staggering statistic.
Some believe that homophobia needs to be addressed at grass roots organisations such as youth clubs. This is of course a necessary step but the initial movement must come from the top.
Professional sport is a presence in every living room and its image has such far reaching influence that homosexuality cannot be adequately normalised without it first providing a model for change.
A lucid quote from Stephen Fry, reacting to Chris Davies’ decision, perhaps unsurprisingly gets to the heart of the matter; “No big deal yet of course a huge deal.”
That is what is needed in Britain’s national sport, people to make that massive statement in order to show that, in the cold light of day, that statement was not so massive at all. Then we can all just get on with the game.

