The Bake Off Blog: Week 8 – Tudor Week
By Simon Fearn
Who’s scarier: Henry VIII or Paul Hollywood? It’s a tough one…
2:00 – Selasi at least is feeling confident this week. He boasts he’s done plenty of historical research and he’s “the only one in the tent that hasn’t won Star Baker, so that’s kind of an achievement in itself.” Hmm…
8:00 – Pies for the Signature. Andrew has taken his engineering prowess to its logical conclusion – a bake based on Da Vinci’s spiral with moving parts and cog-shaped pies! Candice had given herself too much to do as per with two different fillings and two different pastries. One of her pies is also a macaroni cheese pie; I had one from Greggs and it was very disappointing! Benjamina is taking up the Obligatory Unusual (and Perhaps Inappropriate) Flavours mantle, aiming for some Mexican-themed Tudor pies which would surely confuse even the most seasoned of courtiers.
14:00 – In typically organised fashion Andrew’s baking station looks like mission control with four different clocks for his oven times. Selasi has it less together, asking Mel “can I bribe you with pie to buy us some time” – straight to the Tower for him! Candice gives a fine example of Shaky Bake Off Self-Justification, declaring “a pie should have a bit of leakage.” Probably not to be honest… Meanwhile Paul randomly squeezes one of Jane’s pies with no explanation whatsoever and Jane gives him a murderous look.
18:00 – Paul and Mary deliver their verdicts. Jane and Andrew are on top form, while Benjamina has made her characteristic error of getting the flavours right but making “ropey” pastry. Selasi has still not learnt how long to leave things in the oven for, whilst Candice’s grand ambitions come to nought – her macaroni pies are apparently particularly awful.
20:00 – After her disaster, Candice muses “do I want to reign it in a bit?” – we all know full well that she won’t. Here’s hoping she can redeem herself on another obscure Technical: the bakers have to make 12 jumbles (delightfully named knotted Tudor biscuits) in two different designs.
27:00 – This challenge is very period, there are debates about whether using a mixer is too anachronistic and everyone gets to have a go with a mortar and pestle. While Andrew is grinding in a fantastically camp manner, Candice is having a mathematical breakdown and Selasi is tying himself in biscuity knots that look nothing like Paul’s recipe.
33:00 – As the Technical draws to a close Candice is the only one who’s managed to cook the biscuits for long enough and grabs first place. Jane’s in last (her pattern needs more definition apparently) and Selasi somehow gets third despite his knotting dilemmas.
29:00 – Now for a courtly showstopper involving marchpane, the Tudor variant of marzipan. Benjamina’s is very green and involves a maze, which Paul complains is too easy to navigate (it’s only a cake Paul!). Jane is taking fiddly design to the next level, while Selasi’s Tudor research comes in handy in a cake with more symbolism than a Modernist novel. He’s bringing out the booze again and Mary comments “you like a bit of alcohol in your cakes.” Pot kettle Mary!
48:00 – Candice is making a very artistic peacock which is bound to have Mary and Paul raving (despite her nephew saying it looks like playdough), and Andrew’s going for a jousting theme. Selasi’s symbolic masterpiece is looking pretty shoddy, though he of course thinks it’s “so bling”. As Andrew starts to lose his head over crystallising some caramel, one of his jousters is literally decapitated as time runs short.
52:00 – Jane’s marchpane is spectacular, and would not look out of place being gorged upon by King Henry himself. Andrew has a bit of an embarrassing problem: his knights’ jousts are coming very much from their groins, making the latent phallic associations of jousting rather explicit. There are some more complaints about Benjamina’s maze being two easy to solve and she hasn’t bonded her marzipan to the cake. Candice’s peacock is exceptional; Selasi’s marzipan is underdone and looks a bit naff.
54:00 – In an incredibly tense finale, Mary and Paul say either Selasi or Benjamina will go, both of whom I’m emotionally invested in! Star Baker provides some light relief; Jane so thinks she’s got it in the bag, but it deservedly goes to Candice and her peacock. Then the unthinkable happens – since last week I was betting on Selasi’s departure, but it’s Benjamina (my favourite!) who gets the chop. Thankfully Selasi is on hand with a moving tribute: “she’s a proper sister to me, she’s probably the only one that thinks I’m funny.” There’s a proper lump in my throat as Benjamina starts to cry, but the weight of my grief must be put aside for what’s shaping up to be an exciting semi-final!
You don’t want to miss the semi-final: 8pm next Wednesday on BBC One.
Image: Hans Holbein
