The AUKUS Deal: submarines changing the dynamic of world politics
By James Brine
In San Diego last month, Joe Biden, Rishi Sunak and Anthony Albanese announced the AUKUS deal, a tripartite alliance between their 3 nations agreeing to supply Australia with 8 state of the art nuclear-powered submarines by the 2040s, at costs exceeding $368bn. This comes at a time of growing tension in the Indo-Pacific region, largely due to escalating military aggression from China over ongoing disputes in the South China Sea. A historically non-partisan ally to both China and the US, the deal represents a power balance shift as Australia takes a side in the impending battle for global hegemonic status.
The AUKUS deal involves Australia purchasing 3-5 Virginia-class submarines from the US in order to fill the capability gap left between the retirement of their current diesel Collins-class submarines and the entry of the nuclear-powered ones expected in the 2040s. These SSN-AUKUS submarines will comprise of world leading US technological intelligence and UK design expertise to become the superlative of naval capability, making Australia a dominant force in the Indo-Pacific region. One that could, and aims to, rival China.
Australia take a side in the impending battle for global hegemonic status
However this juxtaposes Australia’s traditional stance in foreign policy, that of balancing their US security relationship with their Chinese economic ties. Since 2007 China has been Australia’s largest trade partner, in 2020 alone China bought $102 bn worth (about 25%) of Australian exports and trade with China accounts for over a third of Australia’s total trade. Therefore Australia seeks to maintain a good relationship with China and have largely done so, until the announcement of this deal.
Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs Spokesperson Zhao Lijian said the deal “undermines peace and stability in the region” while another spokesperson warns Australia is “walking further down a path of error and danger”. This hostile reaction is such because China interprets the strengthening of Australian military forces as a stand against their activities in the South China Sea, an area that sees $3.37 tn (about 33%) of global maritime trade pass through it annually.
For China, 80% of their energy imports and almost 40% of their total trade passes through the South China Sea. Thus they have made unwavering claims to the area, substantiated through relentless militarised operations. These have been deemed ‘unlawful’ by the US Department of State and their claims rejected by many, including Australia who say they have no legal basis. The AUKUS deal materialised as a force to counteract this. At least this is the official line.
The Chinese see AUKUS as solidifying the formation of an Anglo-Saxon clique attempting to create a NATO replica in the region. They’re not wrong. The deal overtly represents an intensification of western efforts to assert Western supremacy in the region, out of fear of the consequences of increasing Chinese influence in the South China Sea. Conflict here would threaten 90% of Australia’s fuel imports and cripple the fuel and raw material supply of Western allies South Korea, Japan, and Taiwan so their concerns are justified. The strategic advantage to China were they to control the South China Sea would be detrimental to Australia and the West as a whole. That is the real reason for AUKUS.
The deal overtly represents an intensification of western efforts to assert Western supremacy in the region
The AUKUS deal is a far cry from Australia’s previous approach of peaceful resolution that encouraged multilateral-institution building, with initiatives such as the East Asia Summit. It instead marks one of military intimidation, which aligns with the aims of other key western powers to tilt the power dynamics in their favour in the Indo-Pacific region, something the UK Government confirmed as a permanent pillar of their foreign policy in its 2023 Integrated Review Refresh.
Similarly, the US is committed to strengthening their presence there as it fits into their broader struggle for global hegemonic status. This is because countering China’s burgeoning military capacity requires massive levels of technological, military, and political collaboration with their allies in the area. The importance of which has recently been reiterated vis-à-vis the situation of the proxy diplomatic battleground that is Taiwan. So displaying their power in the area is of paramount tactical importance.
Western perception of AUKUS is it balances power and puts China on their heels in a bid to prevent continued conflict. But perhaps in doing so it is likely to fuel a response from Beijing that may use it as justification for closer cooperation with Russia, a fear only heightened by this month’s meeting of Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin.
Despite widespread bipartisan support for the deal in Canberra, one could express ideological concerns that due to the weakness of Australia’s navy, the submarines will effectively be de facto US submarines, signalling a ceding of Australian sovereignty as they transition to a satellite state. Yet the need for propagating Western power clearly overrides these concerns.
So amidst escalation of neo-cold war anxieties the AUKUS deal ceremoniously symbolises where Australia’s loyalties lie. Putting an end to their active strategy of ambiguity as they back their corner in the fight for global hegemonic status.
Image credit: BAE Systems via Wikimedia Commons

