The Atheist State: Politics and Religion in China

By: April Howard

‘Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people’ wrote Karl Marx in 1844. This statement has formed the spine of Communist states’ approaches to religion. China became Communist in 1949 and is officially an irreligious state. The General Secretary Xi Jinping said that members of the Communist Party in China should be “unyielding Marxist atheists” in 2016. 

Nonetheless, religious interest is growing in China. People are turning to spirituality and faith in a time of economic success and rampant modernisation. This suggests that something about religion calls out to us all, regardless of the ideas of the state or the triumph of the economy.

Indeed, China’s constitution protects citizens’ rights to religious belief, with article 36 protecting “freedom of religious belief”. This freedom, however, is not as clear cut, and Chinese policy is not as accommodating, as this statement may suggest. China observes only 5 religions: Buddhism, Catholicism, Daoism, Islam and Protestantism. Any other faith is prohibited, though often this is not enforced, and therefore expressions of these religions are tolerated.  Religious practices are limited to ‘normal religious activities’ yet the distinction of what classifies as ‘normal’ is not delineated. This, therefore, allows for widely varied interpretation. The right to practice or worship is generally not guaranteed by the constitution. All religious organisations must be registered with one of five religious associations. Religious organisations (or individuals) are also forbidden from compelling citizens to believe (or not believe) in any specific faith.

China is now “one of the world’s most unequal countries”

In February 2018, new regulations were introduced. These regulations increased the capabilities of state- registered religious organisations, allowing them to own property, establish a clergy, accept donations and publish literature. Yet, new restrictions accompany these new freedoms. Donations over 100,000 yuan must be reported, a limit is imposed on times and locations of celebrations as well as general restrictions on religious teaching. 

According to the UN Human Right Council’s Universal Periodic Review (2013), 100 million Chinese citizens are religious (which is less than 10% of the population), yet some independent reports suggest the number to be much greater. Freedom House, one such independent research group, estimates that the number is much more likely to be more than 350 million, consisting primarily of Chinese Buddhists. Another report estimates that the number is in fact 650 million, especially as followers of other faiths or underground churches are frequently left out of data.

So, why is religious sentiment on the increase in a country where religious leaders and groups still feel persecuted and oppressed? The Marxist idea of religion believes that people resort to religion to numb the pain of class oppression and of their social situation, attempting to transcend the material reality and go into another realm, beyond class structures and state affairs. Why, then, in a Communist state with a thriving economy is ‘the opium of the people’ being administered at an increasing rate?

100 million Chinese citizens are religious (which is less than 10% of the population)

Sonali Jain- Chandra published data in 2018 that shows that the Gini coefficient (a standard measure of income inequality) for China has risen since 1990 by 15 points, bringing it to 50. Jain- Chandra states that China is now “one of the world’s most unequal countries”. While measures were introduced to tackle this inequality, namely by increasing minimum wage and the minimum threshold for income taxes, and abolishing agricultural tax. This, however, must go further in order to avoid greater inequality. 

So, perhaps this inequality is driving people towards a spiritual realm, perhaps simply the modernised state has opened up a void spiritually for citizens so they seek to connect to something greater. China remains an irreligious state with tight rules on religious freedom, believers are still in the minority, yet they are a growing, bubbling, determined minority. 

Image: Marina Mestres Segarra