The art of the Christmas television special

By Nicholas Lemieux

Ah, the archetypal Christmas special. A favourite of any TV show regardless of medium or genre. Capitalising on its joyous motifs and story opportunities, the yuletide season has proven a popular setting for many a special episode. After my ramblings last year about Christmas adverts, the only logical next step now would be to fanatically rave about Christmas specials. But compared to adverts that usually come and go, Christmas specials have a more timeless charm to them that makes our enjoyment of them so fascinating. Usually, there’s an extra magical twinge seeing all the usual sets and characters decked out in Christmassy apparel. Many of the storylines generally tend to run along similar beats – Person A tries to get the best present for Person B, awkward Christmas parties, Christmas Carol retellings…  Yet for all their occasionally repetitive nature, they still possess an irresistible quality that prompts us to constantly revisit them over the festive period. So, what is it that makes them stand out?  

The ideal Christmas special is one that features a strong festive backdrop, making the episode stand out from the usual crowd, yet still maintaining the overall spirit of the show. Look no further than the dozen or so Doctor Who Christmas specials that add a festive touch to the bonkers sci-fi concepts the show has become so loved for. Robot Santas, killer Christmas trees, murderous snowmen… in Doctor Who, Christmastime provides no break from extra-terrestrial threats. Yet underneath the usual scares and weird concepts associated with the show, the Christmas specials usually succeed in personifying the heart of the holiday. The magic backdrop of Christmas is an ideal setting for a character as fantastical as the Doctor, and the show wastes no efforts in embracing that fact. 

With ‘Doctor Who‘, you can always bet on enjoying a subversive Christmas adventure

The best example of this would be Matt Smith’s experimental Christmas Carol take. Amidst flying sharks and the usual madcap time travel shenanigans, the special still retains the core values of the original tale as stunningly showcased by Michael Gambon’s Scrooge-like character journey, looking at his past and future through the magic of time travel and ultimately embracing the goodwill of Christmas to become a better man. Cliched and cheesy? Definitely, but it’s presented in such a sincere fashion that it’s hard to dislike. It’s a bittersweet tale that rings extra special during the holidays and it comes perhaps only second to the Muppets in presenting the most enjoyable take of the classic tale. With Doctor Who, you can always bet on enjoying a subversive Christmas adventure and it’s exactly why its absence in the Christmas Day line-up over the last few years has been sorely felt. The recent news that reinstated showrunner Russell T. Davies intends to make Ncuti Gatwa’s first episode as the Doctor a festive special should be met with much rejoice and underlines how something so throwaway as a Christmas special can still retain a special meaning even for a show about to turn sixty. 

For other shows, staying true to their unique strengths can lead to their holiday specials taking unexpected routes that don’t necessarily tie in with the season’s whimsicalness but still carry a comforting meaning. The Christmas specials for South Park and It’s Always Sunny are both some of the bleakest, darkest comedies in existence and in their cases even a feel-good setting like Christmas refuses to compromise their ruthless drive to churn out some truly cringeworthy sequences. However, underneath their mean-spiritedness, the way in which these specials stay true to the cynical themes of their respective shows ensures their entertainment value remains intact.

The sheer fun in simply watching these familiar characters engaging in festive shenanigans is ultimately all you need to create a strong Christmas special

Christmas is a holiday open to much subjective meaning – you’re free to enjoy it in whatever way you want, however its meaning manifests for you. In this way, Christmas specials can take whatever form they want as long as it pleases long-time fans and remains loyal to the show’s initial design. Uplifting shows such as Ted Lasso can go wild with the most whimsical special possible while more pessimistic productions like Peep Show feel more at home with their darker takes. The sheer fun in simply watching these familiar characters engaging in festive shenanigans is ultimately all you need to create a strong Christmas special. 

My personal favourite special would have to be ‘Abed’s Uncontrollable Christmas’ from Community. It’s a perfect showcase of the show’s skill for meta humour, in this case satirising the timeless stop motion productions from Rankin/Bass in the 60s and 70s. Yet the way in which they fit the parody meaningfully within the plot, as an analogy for Abed accepting that even without his mother around Christmas can still have meaning with the help of his friends, elevates its quality immensely. Community was a love letter to all genres of entertainment and its inventive take on Christmas specials here is a prime example of it doing what it does best. Plus, who can resist a Christmas pterodactyl? 

Ultimately, that’s the undeniable art to making Christmas specials. Whatever form they take, wholesome or horrifying, if they stay true to the overall tone and feel of the show, they’ll remain comfort watches everyone can return to each winter. Enjoyment of Christmas can take any form you wish so, irrespective of quality, go ahead and have fun watching whatever has meaning and brings you joy during the holidays.  Even if it’s The Star Wars Holiday Special…

Image: joshua herrera via Unsplash