The arab spring: Israel’s winter of discontent
Having been in the Middle East since April, I have had a wonderful opportunity to experience first- hand the great sweep of changes in Syria, Egypt and across the wider Arab world. My time there has given me a great deal more insight into the region and how the Arab Spring is altering security issues in the Middle East.
Among the vast array of different people I have been able to meet, whether they might be a languages student at Damascus University, a journalist at a high-brow Egyptian newspaper, a liberal-minded protester in Tahrir square or an Arabic teacher sympathetic to the Muslim Brotherhood, they have all been passionate about one issue: Israel-Palestine.
As we have recently seen in New York, the Israelis and the Palestinians seem as far from reaching a lasting settlement as ever. Whilst the Israeli Prime Minister’s speech to the UN General Assembly was a defiant defence of Israel’s current policies and present opposition to Palestinian statehood, the President of the Palestinian Authority, Mahmoud Abbas, has expressed his frustration at the lack of progress in negotiations and the formation of a Palestinian state.
In Egypt, the Mubarak regime (like President Saddat before him) has been seen as an active supporter of Israel. The ousted President’s government helped to maintain the siege of Gaza, supplied gas to Israel at below the market rate and remained passive during the Intifadas and Gaza war. However, grievances against Israel that the Arabs, whom I have met, while studying Arabic in Damascus and Cairo, run deeper than that.
Whilst many Arabs are keen to stress that they have issues with the state of Israel and Zionism – not Jews – anti-Semitic ideas and opinions are not uncommon amongst otherwise perfectly respectful Arabs. Even a liberal Egyptian friend, who will admit hatred of the Muslim Brotherhood, claimed that the numbers of those killed in the holocaust was exaggerated. Many deny the holocaust completely and also claim that no Jews were killed on September 11th. Copies of “Mein Kampf” are in abundance in Arab cities. There is a prevalence of a hatred towards Israel in all levels of Egyptian society; amongst the well-educated and intelligentsia, as well those less ‘well-off.’
Most Arabs will strongly argue that the establishment of Israel was unjust and without legitimacy, annually mourning the Nakba “the catastrophe” that occurred when the Israeli army defeated combined Arab forces and up to 760,000 Palestinians fled their homes.
If democracy does come to flourish in the Arab world, the rules of the game could change significantly.
A democratically elected government in Egypt would have to address its people’s desire for a change in its relationship with Israel.
Israel could no longer claim to be the only democracy in the Middle East, surrounded by hostile dictatorial regimes.
Moreover, if democratically elected Arab governments seek a peaceful resolution, the Jewish state cannot not afford to reject them. In order to build partnerships in the region and rebuild old ones, with countries like Turkey, Israel must champion the cause of human rights in its neighbours. I suggest hatred of Israel in Arab countries could be kept in check by both moderate parties in government in Arab states alongside Israel reaching out to the Palestinians and allowing them to build a state of their own.
Pragmatic Arab leaders accept the presence of Israel; those against could be brought round by an Israel which stops the development of settlements outside of the pre-1967 borders and enacts mutually agreeable land swaps for existing settlements and, ultimately, allows a sovereign Palestinian state. The more stable the region, and the more development Arab countries experience, the less likely opposition to the state of Israel will be. Israel will ensure its security, if surrounded by stable, economically viable, democratic states, including a Palestinian one

