The Anti-Sitcom
By Hugh Johnson
It’s Always Sunny, the depraved and hilarious US sitcom, has just entered it’s 13th Season, tying it with the show The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet as the longest running sitcom on American TV. The show, created and written by Rob McElhenney, Charlie Day and Glenn Howerton, owes a great deal of its success to being an anti-sitcom. In an interview before season 7 aired, Rob McElhenney, who plays Mac, talks about how in all sitcoms the characters seem to get better over time, or look better. He remarked that he had never seen a show where the characters or actors made an effort to look worse as the show progressed. This led him to gain 50 pounds before Season 7 of the show, and it is through his observations about the standard sitcom that we can begin to see Always Sunny for the anti-sitcom it really is.
To see how Always Sunny has achieved this anti-sitcom status, we must first explore what a sitcom is. A sitcom, or situation comedy, is a comedic genre focused on a fixed set of characters. Sitcoms are often recorded in front of a live studio audience or feature a laugh track. Examples of this include Friends, the Big Bang Theory, How I Met Your Mother and Seinfeld. Sitcoms also normally follow a formulaic structure, with characters growing up and bettering themselves as the show goes on. Take Friends, where in season 1 Chandler can’t hold down a relationship and is in a dead-end job, and Rachel is spoiled and a waitress. By the final season, Chandler is married, a father, and in a job he likes, and Rachel has worked her way into a high executive position in the fashion industry.
Always Sunny can be seen to be a traditional sitcom in some senses, as it focuses on a fixed set of characters, normally set in the bar that they own, as they go about their problematic lives. But in many ways, Always Sunny totally breaks from the traditional sitcom formula. Take Frank’s entrance into the show in Season 2. He begins as a wealthy businessman going through a divorce who wants to reconnect with his kids and give his money to charity. As the show goes on, he seems to get more and more insane and depraved, and by Season 13 he is an unpredictable, gun toting, drug-taking lunatic. This demonstrates how the characters in Always Sunny decline – rather than improve – as the seasons continue.
In Season 12, episode 3, entitled ‘Old Lady House: A Situation Comedy’, the show directly mocks other sitcoms. The ironic use of a laugh track as the characters decide to make their own sitcom about Charlie and Mac’s mothers highlights how the show feels about the state of modern situation comedy. At one point, Charlie remarks that he likes watching their comedy, ‘Old Lady House’ with the added laugh track, because it ‘tells him when to laugh’. Always Sunny’s decision to not have a laugh track, and to go against the entire formula of the standard sitcom, is nicely summed up in this episode.
Season 13 can be seen to embody the show’s decision to continue its anti-sitcom structure. With Dennis leaving at the end of Season 12, there were fears that the show was turning a new corner and becoming less outrageous and more like a standard sitcom. This was highlighted by Dennis’s replacement, Mindy Kaling, who from the outset was seemingly trying to better the gang. For most Always Sunny fans, this represented the show turning its back on the old ways and, possibly, it’s anti-sitcom status. But Dennis’s return at the end of Season 13, episode 1, is representative of how the characters in Always Sunny are destined to continue their downward spiral and not fall victim to the common traps of comedy television; and crucially, to not change. In my opinion, this is what makes It’s Always Sunny so great.
Image by Rob Benigno via Google Images
