The allocation debate: a Castle response

By Isaac Turner

As a student at Castle, I believe that the automated allocation system being trialed on the new cohort of students should be permanently put in place. This method of distributing applicants to colleges automatically allows students the first choice in the case of no over-subscription, instead of relying on senior tutors to select those they think would ‘fit in best to’ or ‘most suitably match’ their specific, often non-transparent criteria.

Durham_Castle_Eingang

There are three main reasons why automatic allocations would be progressive for Durham. The first is that the old system engenders a culture of superiority and elitism. Those at Bailey colleges, and perhaps most specifically Castle, are immediately treated to a sumptuous banquet of formals, balls, historic architecture, cultural heritage and close proximity to the town centre.

Knowing you were picked specifically by a Bailey college’s senior tutor can often lead to a sense of entitlement, that you are, in some way, ‘more appropriate’ in comparison to those on the Hill. This should absolutely not be the case. Automatic allocations will significantly reduce any presence of the key issue, selection, and instil a greater feeling of equality and fairness.

Secondly, the new system will ensure that those who do not get into their first choice will not feel personally rejected, often due to an arbitrary set of requirements that should have no bearing on allocations. The focus should be on student choice, not college choice. Durham doesn’t have the Oxbridge college system, nor does it have the resources to individually interview all its applicants.

The focus should be on student choice, not college choice

If I decide I want to be at Hatfield, Van Mildert or Chad’s, I should be accepted on the basis of my own personal preference, rather than that of someone I have never met. A personal statement is very limited in its ability to convey an individual’s personality or attributes and, as such, should not be the deciding factor in which college they are allocated. If Durham is to truly work for its students, it must accommodate their preferences in a more extensive manner.

The final reason is that the new system will also encourage a greater mix of individuals within each college. Of course, it is important to preserve the unique atmosphere and qualities of individual colleges. That is one of the reasons we find Durham so special, and some say senior utors should remain in control. But suddenly banning, say, Castle from picking its ‘ideal type’ will not suddenly translate into a loss of enthusiasm for formals and college music nights in the Undie.

It will not lead to a decrease in the passion its members have for rowing, community action or musical theatre. Rather, a mix of individuals within each college will result in a pooling of abilities and a diversification of talents. When visiting friends at St Aidan’s, I am often surprised by how different they are to my friends at Castle. What would be even better is the chance to have all of those personalities under one roof.

Although I openly welcome criticism of my arguments, I find it hard to see how the new system provides a worse deal for students when we consider the improvements to equality and cohesion that it will bring. I for one look forward to welcoming my college children next year, in the knowledge that they chose my college, not that my college chose them. 

Photograph: Durham University