Thatcher deserves a place in history, but not legend

DF-SC-83-02198

by Michael Laughton

Baroness Thatcher is undeniably the defining figure of the 1980s. The first, and so far only, woman prime minister. Without a doubt the saviour of the Falklands, whatever her personal prevarications. Her premiership changed lives as few can claim to. Her place in history is assured – but we must resist her place in legend.

The Prime Minister, however, has misused Parliament for a political agenda – his own. By attempting to elevate Thatcher to the ranks of Churchill, Attlee and Nelson, he is trying to add legitimacy to his tribute act, adding the gravitas he has lost since 2012.

Just as the beard does not make the philosopher, a ceremonial funeral does not make a stateswoman. The memorial to the miners in Durham Cathedral stands as a monument to ridicule the idea that she was universally greeted as the saviour of our nation.

Praise of her has been mainly hyperbole but criticism relatively tame. This is the evidence of the impact she had on our politics. Much of what resulted from her premiership nobody would dream of reversing. But this is not quite praise. Few would bring back the dead but they wouldn’t have killed them either.

On her own terms, Thatcher was undeniably successful, second perhaps only to Clement Attlee, much of whose work she undid. Inflation fell massively in her tenure. The only major state-owned industry left in 1990 was British Rail – and her successor sold it off. We did become the property-owning nation she desired. The unions were emasculated. Where before they overthrew governments, now they are laughed at by government front benches.

But let us remember the consequences. Four million people unemployed – one million of which were shifted to Incapacity Benefit. Eleven riots took place in her tenure, either against the police or against her policies. She altered neither. Whole towns and communities were bereft of the opportunity she claimed to spread and little of her famously freed enterprise bothered to go up North. As a result, a huge chunk of North Sea oil money went on papering over the cracks in society, rather than investing to repair it.

The Conservatives who are singing hymns for her must know she is still the reason they have twice as many pandas in Scotland than MPs. If the Union is lost in 2014, blame can be placed squarely at her feet. It is Thatcher that brought the Nasty Party and it is telling that her successor wouldn’t dare appoint a Conservative as Secretary of State for Scotland.

It was her government that was responsible for the “Big Bang” in the City. It took 30 years for the debris to blow back in our faces but surely she deserves much of the blame for the deification of bankers and the poisonous culture it still represents.

While it was her government that took the lead in evidence-based HIV/AIDS policy, it was still in Thatcher’s Britain that people were frightened that teaching children about homosexuality would engender it.

Thatcher has passed on at a crucial moment in our history when the senior Coalition party is baying for the classics – tax cuts, shrink the state and on yer bike. Her legacy must be deconstructed before it is entrenched. That way, TINA – There Is No Alternative – can become Never Again.